As a comics expert, I’ve been doing some research into the plagiarism allegations against this comic.
My final analysis is that there are too many similarities to just chalk them up to ‘great minds.’ Of course that still doesn’t mean a ruling of ‘plagiarism’ is justified. One would have to know more about the writers state of mind and his or her motivations.
Final judgment: Charges dismissed due to lack of sufficient evidence.
what do you mean? I never said I didn’t like the comic.
There were articles on The Daily Cartoonist, The Washington Post, Google and Pooch Cafe’s Web site talking about these artists stealing material from another cartoonist.
I’m merely offering my expert advice on the matter.
For what it’s worth, many cartoonists study each others’ work and are often good friends. They freely admit that they “bounce” ideas off each other with no offense taken when the themes are shared…
COWBOY7 about 14 years ago
Don’t listen to him! You’ll be sorry.
Lyons Group, Inc. about 14 years ago
Okay, what did he just do?
lightblade77 about 14 years ago
He’s covering up the white fur with black paint.
GROG Premium Member about 14 years ago
I wouldn’t go for that innocent routine.
Destiny23 about 14 years ago
So that’s why you can’t trust pit bulls!
Dry and Dusty Premium Member about 14 years ago
Kenny you should know by now not to trust Will!
Comicsexpert about 14 years ago
As a comics expert, I’ve been doing some research into the plagiarism allegations against this comic.
My final analysis is that there are too many similarities to just chalk them up to ‘great minds.’ Of course that still doesn’t mean a ruling of ‘plagiarism’ is justified. One would have to know more about the writers state of mind and his or her motivations.
Final judgment: Charges dismissed due to lack of sufficient evidence.
Dry and Dusty Premium Member about 14 years ago
comicsexpert????? You seem to be the only one making that claim that I’ve seen!
Comicsexpert about 14 years ago
What do you mean DryCula?
GROG Premium Member about 14 years ago
comixexpert, you are the only one I see complaining about plagiarism.
Really, if you don’t like the strip, why do you bother coming here?
Comicsexpert about 14 years ago
what do you mean? I never said I didn’t like the comic.
There were articles on The Daily Cartoonist, The Washington Post, Google and Pooch Cafe’s Web site talking about these artists stealing material from another cartoonist.
I’m merely offering my expert advice on the matter.
Dry and Dusty Premium Member about 14 years ago
Again, “expert advice?”
Comicsexpert about 14 years ago
Sorry if you don’t like what I am saying.
Dry and Dusty Premium Member about 14 years ago
Just curious what makes you the expert, as you called yourself.
craigwestlake about 14 years ago
For what it’s worth, many cartoonists study each others’ work and are often good friends. They freely admit that they “bounce” ideas off each other with no offense taken when the themes are shared…
harsha213 over 13 years ago
nice comic…….its awsome..
Odie's best friend almost 3 years ago
OoO woah