This is a rarity: the equations shown actually make sense in this context. Usually cartoonists just write nonsense — Bill Amend being a notable exception, because he has a bachelor’s degree in physics. My guess is that the dog’s thought bubble was sampled from some textbook; if not, I’m even more impressed.
Unfortunately, the equations shown are really more appropriate for a nonrotating ball, not a Frisbee; they include drag, but not lift. They would not even do a good job predicting the path of a curve ball. Even so, the equations lack simple solutions and have to be estimated numerically, which is why there is a reference to Excel and Euler’s Method at the bottom.
The human brain solves differential equations in real time. We are pretty good analog computers.
Watson, the computer that beat the Jeopardy champs, weighed in at about a half ton and used close to a kilowatt of power.
Our brains weigh about 4 pounds (2% of body weight) and use 12.5 watts of power (20% – 25% of the total energy of the body). 12.5 watts is about half as bright as the bulb in the back of the refrigerator.
What we lack in mass and power, we make up for in efficiency.
Human brain is not more efficient than other mammals’ brains.https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/human-brain-is-not-more-efficient-than-other-mammals-brains
Concretionist over 2 years ago
I have heard that outfielders just run until the apparent path of the ball is straight at them. No math at all.
Doug K over 2 years ago
Just because the dog has it memorized doesn’t mean he understands it.
Jayalexander over 2 years ago
Ha, ha, ha. People are so dumb they keep throwing their stuff away.
zerotvus over 2 years ago
baloney! that dog is figuring his treat rate…….
AtariDragon over 2 years ago
This is a rarity: the equations shown actually make sense in this context. Usually cartoonists just write nonsense — Bill Amend being a notable exception, because he has a bachelor’s degree in physics. My guess is that the dog’s thought bubble was sampled from some textbook; if not, I’m even more impressed.
Unfortunately, the equations shown are really more appropriate for a nonrotating ball, not a Frisbee; they include drag, but not lift. They would not even do a good job predicting the path of a curve ball. Even so, the equations lack simple solutions and have to be estimated numerically, which is why there is a reference to Excel and Euler’s Method at the bottom.
dflak over 2 years ago
The human brain solves differential equations in real time. We are pretty good analog computers.
Watson, the computer that beat the Jeopardy champs, weighed in at about a half ton and used close to a kilowatt of power.
Our brains weigh about 4 pounds (2% of body weight) and use 12.5 watts of power (20% – 25% of the total energy of the body). 12.5 watts is about half as bright as the bulb in the back of the refrigerator.
What we lack in mass and power, we make up for in efficiency.
Zen-of-Zinfandel over 2 years ago
Don’t toss it towards the poison oak, that’s where he draws the line.
Daltongang Premium Member over 2 years ago
Human brain is not more efficient than other mammals’ brains.https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/human-brain-is-not-more-efficient-than-other-mammals-brains
timinwsac Premium Member over 2 years ago
Well it ain’t rocket surgery.
WCraft Premium Member over 2 years ago
Humans are the silly ones. Can’t decide if they wish to throw away the frisbee/ball/stick or if they want it back!
Lightpainter over 2 years ago
What would a dog think of a boomerang?
boltjenkins1 over 2 years ago
Should be a cat
oakie817 over 2 years ago
only dumb animals are humans