Looks like the beginning of a time travel story; tomorrow they’ll step into a police box and cause a catastrophe, then they’ll try to fix it with a Delorean.
On his way out the door to lunch, a man asked his secretary to confirm his flight to a nearby city for the next day. At lunch the man read a fortune cookie that said “You will die in an airplane accident tomorrow.” Upon returning to the office the man told his secretary to cancel his flight and rent him a car to drive instead. As the man approached his destination the next day, the plane he would have taken, flew overhead and lost a motor which plummeted to the ground and crushed the man in his car.
Rat says ‘how and when’, but not where. So anyone that said yes, they’d like to know, would have only the knowledge to worry about dying, but they would die anyway. You can’t avoid a ‘when’ and a ‘how’ can be easily manipulated into striking you down anyway. All it would get you is a chance to say goodbye, and you would seem insane for doing it, and people would say you caused your own death by thinking it.
Finally thought of Macbeth. The “second apparition” told him that “none of woman born/Shall harm Macbeth.” So Macbeth was afraid of no man. However, he was killed by Macduff. who was not “born” of woman, but delivered by cesarean.
Robert A. Heinlein wrote a short story about this. A scientist creates such a device and the academy goes nuts. And mobs him and kill him somehow after destroying the device. They find an envelope on the scientist with his own death date.
In the first Disc World book Terry Pratchett wrote about a psychic who read the future and knew about the big fire in AnkeMorepork and knew she was going to die so she gathered up her whole family and left the city the day before the fire. Then when the fire happened everyone escaped without a scratch but the psychic’s wagon was caught in a landslide in the mountains and she was killed. The moral of the story is that trying to avoid your own death can actually cause it.
Sadly too many people seem to have Pig’s response. If you now the exact how and when of your death then you can “escape” it. Yet knowing the exact how and when means you can’t escape it.
Imagine being told you will die at 9:30 PM on October 21, 2015 when a car hits you. You’d want to make sure you weren’t on the road or even out at that time of night to keep from getting hit by a car, right. If you’re not out you can escape death. So there you are on October 21, 2015 watching TV in you’re living room, knowing your safe when right at 9:30 PM an out of control car comes barreling through the wall, hitting you and killing you instantly.
I read a story once, though I don’t remember its name or the name of the author. A man looks into the future and sees himself as a helpless invalid, lying in bed hooked up to all kinds of medical machinery. He doesn’t want to have that happen, so he shoots himself in the head. But he doesn’t die, and he ends up a helpless invalid, lying in bed hooked up to all kinds of medical machinery…
RuinQueenofOblivion about 11 years ago
While technically impossible, Pig actually kinda has a point here.
Sherlock Watson about 11 years ago
Looks like the beginning of a time travel story; tomorrow they’ll step into a police box and cause a catastrophe, then they’ll try to fix it with a Delorean.
Ida No about 11 years ago
Rat: “No, Pig, you’re a liar.”
zero about 11 years ago
I’m with Pig
hariseldon59 about 11 years ago
For some reason I’m reminded of this classic Pearls strip from 2002.
http://www.gocomics.com/pearlsbeforeswine/2002/01/31#.UlOamiTB1jc
corzak about 11 years ago
Pig is creating temporal paradox. Similarly, I must now go back in time to this Pearls strip and stop myself from writing a comment.
jazzmoose about 11 years ago
Just tell me where; I can take it from there.
PICTO about 11 years ago
On his way out the door to lunch, a man asked his secretary to confirm his flight to a nearby city for the next day. At lunch the man read a fortune cookie that said “You will die in an airplane accident tomorrow.” Upon returning to the office the man told his secretary to cancel his flight and rent him a car to drive instead. As the man approached his destination the next day, the plane he would have taken, flew overhead and lost a motor which plummeted to the ground and crushed the man in his car.
Sisyphos about 11 years ago
Dunno about that, Pig. You just might be….
Defective Premium Member about 11 years ago
Rat says ‘how and when’, but not where. So anyone that said yes, they’d like to know, would have only the knowledge to worry about dying, but they would die anyway. You can’t avoid a ‘when’ and a ‘how’ can be easily manipulated into striking you down anyway. All it would get you is a chance to say goodbye, and you would seem insane for doing it, and people would say you caused your own death by thinking it.
joeshmo30 about 11 years ago
hay, im with pig here, id want to know so i could avoid death:P
Enoki about 11 years ago
Just make sure you are well armed and kill death first. That way you can avoid it.
Carl Rennhack Premium Member about 11 years ago
Pig should read the story “The Appointment in Samarra (as retold by W. Somerset Maugham)”
corzak about 11 years ago
@finaleHelp…
Vet Premium Member about 11 years ago
I side with Pig on this one.
Gokie5 about 11 years ago
Finally thought of Macbeth. The “second apparition” told him that “none of woman born/Shall harm Macbeth.” So Macbeth was afraid of no man. However, he was killed by Macduff. who was not “born” of woman, but delivered by cesarean.
Potrzebie about 11 years ago
Robert A. Heinlein wrote a short story about this. A scientist creates such a device and the academy goes nuts. And mobs him and kill him somehow after destroying the device. They find an envelope on the scientist with his own death date.
tazz555 about 11 years ago
I wonldnt want to know when and how Id die. For one Id dread every day keading to it. I might try to avoid it and actually cause it
xpurplezebra about 11 years ago
True, You’re off more than on.
natureboyfig4 Premium Member about 11 years ago
As a certain spider would say: “Some pig!”
155088 about 11 years ago
Where the $% did the Crocs go?
Number Three about 11 years ago
Sorry, Pig.
xxx
patlaborvi about 11 years ago
In the first Disc World book Terry Pratchett wrote about a psychic who read the future and knew about the big fire in AnkeMorepork and knew she was going to die so she gathered up her whole family and left the city the day before the fire. Then when the fire happened everyone escaped without a scratch but the psychic’s wagon was caught in a landslide in the mountains and she was killed. The moral of the story is that trying to avoid your own death can actually cause it.
knight1192a about 11 years ago
Sadly too many people seem to have Pig’s response. If you now the exact how and when of your death then you can “escape” it. Yet knowing the exact how and when means you can’t escape it.
Imagine being told you will die at 9:30 PM on October 21, 2015 when a car hits you. You’d want to make sure you weren’t on the road or even out at that time of night to keep from getting hit by a car, right. If you’re not out you can escape death. So there you are on October 21, 2015 watching TV in you’re living room, knowing your safe when right at 9:30 PM an out of control car comes barreling through the wall, hitting you and killing you instantly.
finnygirl Premium Member about 11 years ago
I read a story once, though I don’t remember its name or the name of the author. A man looks into the future and sees himself as a helpless invalid, lying in bed hooked up to all kinds of medical machinery. He doesn’t want to have that happen, so he shoots himself in the head. But he doesn’t die, and he ends up a helpless invalid, lying in bed hooked up to all kinds of medical machinery…
codedaddy about 11 years ago
So Pig is admitting to being an imbecile (the next lower category) or even an idiot (the lowest category).
SwimsWithSharks about 11 years ago
I’m reminded of a strip Stephan will write next year.
PBS1! over 3 years ago
Ngl I agree with Pig. Even if I had no ability to prevent it, I could plan accordingly.