But wouldn’t he just go look for evidence of the bomb?Being the world’s greatest detective and having one clue with no obvious usefulness, he would seek out other avenues.Occupying the mind with other matters is often the best way to resolve an impasse.
@ThreeStepsOverJapanSure, but if he solves the clue and the real parts aren’t 0.5, then he still doesn’t know whether there’s a bomb. Whether he works at solving the clue or looking for evidence, he only works on the antecedent of a conditional whose consequent is that a bomb is beneath a downtown dive. In neither case can he be assured that there is not one. However, if he looks and doesn’t find one, then he has some evidence that there isn’t one, evidence that goes beyond the conversational implicature of a crook known for twisting language.
Ida No almost 10 years ago
On a plus note, it means that Batman’s not past his primes yet.
Brass Orchid Premium Member almost 10 years ago
But wouldn’t he just go look for evidence of the bomb?Being the world’s greatest detective and having one clue with no obvious usefulness, he would seek out other avenues.Occupying the mind with other matters is often the best way to resolve an impasse.
emptc12 almost 10 years ago
Dr. Matrix might have made an interesting villain..a, b …………..………………….………………….………………..c
Coyoty Premium Member almost 10 years ago
Sometimes you just can’t get a riddle of a bomb.
drnihili almost 10 years ago
@ThreeStepsOverJapanSure, but if he solves the clue and the real parts aren’t 0.5, then he still doesn’t know whether there’s a bomb. Whether he works at solving the clue or looking for evidence, he only works on the antecedent of a conditional whose consequent is that a bomb is beneath a downtown dive. In neither case can he be assured that there is not one. However, if he looks and doesn’t find one, then he has some evidence that there isn’t one, evidence that goes beyond the conversational implicature of a crook known for twisting language.
scyphi26 almost 10 years ago
Darn that Riddler…I bet he’s ruined a great many weekends for Batman because of riddles like that one.
Stephen Gilberg almost 10 years ago
For once, the Riddler outdoes the Joker.
jhodell Premium Member almost 10 years ago
You guys are overthinking it. The point of the comic is that Zach wants us all to know that he knows some esoteric math. Congrats, Zach!
Paige Turner over 5 years ago
The bomb isn’t there because there are infinitely many y=0 where x <> .5