I was pulling for Spiders. I get the local connection to Guardians, but it sounds like a third-class indoor football team. Just my opinion, and they didn’t ask for it.
Cleveland Guardians is already used by a roller derby team. They are suing the baseball team for copyright infringement. Maybe “Flaming Rivers” would be a better name for the baseballers.
It seems to me that the use of names such as “Indians” became controversial before, probably in the late 1960’s or early 1970’s. Because of this, Stanford University changed their mascot from “Indians” to “Cardinal”, which was fine. But what confused me and my naive self was, why did Stanford have to change their name, when the Cleveland Indians, whose depiction of an Indian in the form of Chief Wahoo seemed vastly more demeaning than anything Stanford used, did not? At least Cleveland and the Washington Football Team finally got with the program, even if it was 45 to 50 years late.
sergioandrade Premium Member over 3 years ago
As Cleveland fans say “Let’s root, root, root for the home team. If they don’t win what else is new.”
jeff_e over 3 years ago
“Rockers” was too close to “Rockies.” They should have just become the Cleveland Rocks. What a missed opportunity.
derdave969 over 3 years ago
I’d vote for Flames or Flamers (Cuyahoga River fire).
Lotus over 3 years ago
I was pulling for Spiders. I get the local connection to Guardians, but it sounds like a third-class indoor football team. Just my opinion, and they didn’t ask for it.
jagedlo over 3 years ago
“Rockers”…since the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame is in Cleveland?
Guilty Bystander over 3 years ago
There WAS a team called the Cleveland Rockers. They were one of the eight original WNBA teams.
And I liked Cleveland Spiders too. Cleveland Guardians sounds like a home alarm system.
Ellis97 over 3 years ago
There are so many cursed names, that it’s practically impossible to say anything.
For a Just and Peaceful World over 3 years ago
Since Cleveland is considered to be The Mistake by the Lake, what about The Cleveland Mistakes?
Vangoghdog01 over 3 years ago
My wife’s family came from Norway, I have yet to hear any of that huge bunch of people complain about a NFL team called the Vikings.
Linguist over 3 years ago
The Cleveland Guardians … sounds like something you’d hear on Hysterical Channel’s Ancient Aliens faux programs.
paul GROSS Premium Member over 3 years ago
So is the idea to remove any reference to native Americans and just forget they ever existed?
gmu328 over 3 years ago
I personally liked their old name – the Cleveland Spiders. Could have even spelled it “Spyders” to shake things up.
Teto85 Premium Member over 3 years ago
Cleveland Guardians is already used by a roller derby team. They are suing the baseball team for copyright infringement. Maybe “Flaming Rivers” would be a better name for the baseballers.
Sailor46 USN 65-95 over 3 years ago
I’m still thinking pilfering the Space Force’s name is…, Well it’s the Space Force….
BlueKnight1966 over 3 years ago
They should have kept the “I” to reflect what was truly happening, and called them “Cleveland Idiots”.
Blaidd Drwg Premium Member over 3 years ago
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j1G2l_A9nB0&ab_channel=RiceNFish
mysterysciencefreezer over 3 years ago
“Spiders” was right there.
WF11 over 3 years ago
It seems to me that the use of names such as “Indians” became controversial before, probably in the late 1960’s or early 1970’s. Because of this, Stanford University changed their mascot from “Indians” to “Cardinal”, which was fine. But what confused me and my naive self was, why did Stanford have to change their name, when the Cleveland Indians, whose depiction of an Indian in the form of Chief Wahoo seemed vastly more demeaning than anything Stanford used, did not? At least Cleveland and the Washington Football Team finally got with the program, even if it was 45 to 50 years late.