This reminds me of the claim that all religious beliefs are good and equally valid. I responded with the claim my religious belief is that all others are invalid, that only mine was the right one.“Well, you’re just wrong!”“If I’m wrong, then your belief that all are good and valid is wrong.”They could both be wrong or the first wrong and mine could be right but the first can’t be right if the second is right and since the first rejects the teachings of the second, logically it MUST be wrong whether the second is right or wrong.
rdh288 about 15 years ago
Trout found the fatal flaw pretty quick.
David Huie Green AmericaIsGreatItHasUs about 12 years ago
This reminds me of the claim that all religious beliefs are good and equally valid. I responded with the claim my religious belief is that all others are invalid, that only mine was the right one.“Well, you’re just wrong!”“If I’m wrong, then your belief that all are good and valid is wrong.”They could both be wrong or the first wrong and mine could be right but the first can’t be right if the second is right and since the first rejects the teachings of the second, logically it MUST be wrong whether the second is right or wrong.