Sorry, Milo, but the tired aphorism is correct nonetheless. If you have eaten your cake, you no longer “have” it.Binkley, butt out! I’m the grammar cop on this beat!
My house mate is one of those who tend to just toss words out there, with no thought to their order. He thinks that as long as he uses the right words, never mind there order, they mean exactly what is in his head. He also mixes metaphors, and consistently uses wrong words. Carafate (a drug) for carafe, for example. This is the same person I recently mentioned says “rurned” for ruined.
And he’s got a good paying job as a critical care nurse in the local hospital. Go figure.
Cakes are usually quite big. Unless it’s a cupcake, but then you would say cupcake. I usually eat only one piece depending on the cake, that is at most 1/6th of the whole cake. So I do usually eat my cake and have my cake… at least five times per cake.
Sisyphos about 11 years ago
Sorry, Milo, but the tired aphorism is correct nonetheless. If you have eaten your cake, you no longer “have” it.Binkley, butt out! I’m the grammar cop on this beat!
edclectic about 11 years ago
It’ll all come out in the end.
alviebird about 11 years ago
Is that supposed to be his Will Rogers hat?
erik.vanthienen about 11 years ago
“Kit and caboodle”! Sheesh …
Sisyphus1967 about 11 years ago
It doesn’t make sense to people because nobody says it right. It’s “you can’t eat your cake and have it too”, meaning you can’t have it both ways.
This phrase is a perfect example of why you shouldn’t mindlessly repeat everything you hear without stopping to think what it means.
bbadenov about 11 years ago
Penguins have lips?
alviebird about 11 years ago
My house mate is one of those who tend to just toss words out there, with no thought to their order. He thinks that as long as he uses the right words, never mind there order, they mean exactly what is in his head. He also mixes metaphors, and consistently uses wrong words. Carafate (a drug) for carafe, for example. This is the same person I recently mentioned says “rurned” for ruined.
And he’s got a good paying job as a critical care nurse in the local hospital. Go figure.
1MadHat Premium Member about 11 years ago
And the great rhetoric, worthy of Mrs. Malaprop herself, the mixed metaphor of: “ain’t no skin off my stiff upper lip”. 8^)
sbchamp about 11 years ago
Whur haz da caboodles gone?
Strod about 11 years ago
Cakes are usually quite big. Unless it’s a cupcake, but then you would say cupcake. I usually eat only one piece depending on the cake, that is at most 1/6th of the whole cake. So I do usually eat my cake and have my cake… at least five times per cake.
ChessPirate about 11 years ago
Hey, a rolling stone is worth two in the bush.
tbritt99 about 11 years ago
You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make him run up the hill to fetch a pail.
Black4dder about 11 years ago
I think ‘the whole kit and caboose’ should become a standard phrase.
I Play One On TV about 11 years ago
You can pick your friends.
And you can pick your nose.
But you can’t pick your friend’s nose.
alviebird about 11 years ago
Works both ways. And although it has a little different meaning, your way sounds better. Maybe I should have said “…proper order.”