I always thought the contempt of court rule, broke the right to a fair trial for every crime, innocent until proven guilty, did the jury agree with the judge?
DreamScourge: “I always thought the contempt of court rule, broke the right to a fair trial for every crime, innocent until proven guilty, did the jury agree with the judge?”
I’m not sure what you mean. If you’re actually a criminal defendant, you have a right not to testify, or to choose not to answer a specific question, but if you DO testify you’re still obliged to tell the truth. If you’re subpoenaed as a witness in a trial, you can’t invoke the 5th Amendment; absent a valid reason for keeping a privilege (a priest, a doctor, an attorney, sometimes a journalist), you HAVE to answer the questions.
What bugs me in movies and TV shows and such is when a witness is browbeaten into answering simply “Yes” or “No” to a question, when they obviously feel that elaboration is necessary. Sometimes “Yes” or “No” is the truth but it isn’t the WHOLE truth, and by not allowing me to elaborate you’re making me perjure myself.
margueritem almost 14 years ago
Sounds just like a politian
Llewellenbruce almost 14 years ago
I think you’re under contemp of court.
Charles Evans Premium Member almost 14 years ago
Broomie should get a medal for being truthful, not a contempt citation.
Yukoner almost 14 years ago
Broomie, I told you not to get carried away.
tirnaaisling almost 14 years ago
I always thought the contempt of court rule, broke the right to a fair trial for every crime, innocent until proven guilty, did the jury agree with the judge?
Maybe Broomie holds the court in contempt!
lewisbower almost 14 years ago
If Congressmen acted like that, nothing would get done
GROG Premium Member almost 14 years ago
That was contemptible, Broomie.
wicky almost 14 years ago
Witches cannot swear on Bibles.
linsonl almost 14 years ago
She didn’t.
fritzoid Premium Member almost 14 years ago
DreamScourge: “I always thought the contempt of court rule, broke the right to a fair trial for every crime, innocent until proven guilty, did the jury agree with the judge?”
I’m not sure what you mean. If you’re actually a criminal defendant, you have a right not to testify, or to choose not to answer a specific question, but if you DO testify you’re still obliged to tell the truth. If you’re subpoenaed as a witness in a trial, you can’t invoke the 5th Amendment; absent a valid reason for keeping a privilege (a priest, a doctor, an attorney, sometimes a journalist), you HAVE to answer the questions.
What bugs me in movies and TV shows and such is when a witness is browbeaten into answering simply “Yes” or “No” to a question, when they obviously feel that elaboration is necessary. Sometimes “Yes” or “No” is the truth but it isn’t the WHOLE truth, and by not allowing me to elaborate you’re making me perjure myself.
Totalloser Premium Member almost 14 years ago
Broom Hilda is ready to be the next President of the United States
Phatts almost 14 years ago
And this, my friends, is How You Get Out of Jury Duty.
SaunaBeach almost 14 years ago
I had a t-shirt that said, “If Bulls h i t was music, I’d be a Brass Band”.
RinaFarina almost 14 years ago
I once went to vote and had to re-register because I had moved to a new address. They wanted me to swear on the four holy gospels.
I said, “I can’t do that! I don’t swear on the gospels - I’m not a Christian!”
and they said “We don’t mind!”
idiots!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I forget how I did it, but I didn’t swear on the gospels, and I did get to vote.
ponytail56 almost 14 years ago
I’ve seen some courts that you just can’t feel anyting but contempt for
Ooops! Premium Member almost 14 years ago
Broomie, if you are going to lie, don’t tell people you are going to lie………………………. (sadly shakes head)