June: Penny, why aren't you eating your tomato?
Penny: I don't like vegetables!
June: Tomatoes are a fruit!
Penny: Oh, no they're not! If tomatoes are a fruit, how come they don't have tomato-flavored snow-cones?
It depends on who gets to decide the meanings of the words: botanists or everybody else. Why should they get to decide on the definitions of words in the English language? That’s the job of dictionaries, not scientists!
I say a tomato is a vegetable because that’s the way the word is used in the English language. Let scientists use their own jargon however they want, but don’t make me use the definitions they’ve made up for their own use.
Technically, any part of the plant that contains the seeds is a fruit. Tomatoes are fruit, as are cucumbers, pumpkins, corn cobs, etc. Technically, a vegetable is any food that comes from a plants. Therefore a tomato and all of the above are both fruit and vegetable.
Set aside your political leanings for a moment — as well as the unproductive fruit/vegetable argument. If you look up the nutritional value of ketchup, you will see that it has plenty of nutritional value. Not as much as tomato soup, perhaps, but more than some vegetables that you wouldn’t scoff at. It makes perfect sense to count the nutritional contribution of ketchup as part of the nutritional value of the whole meal. -BTW, here’s a link to the best (free) website on food nutrition facts that I’ve ever found on-line:-http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/vegetables-and-vegetable-products/3015/2
Twinkly lights over 10 years ago
How about some tomato flavored ice cream?Or perhaps some carrot/orange?
JanBic Premium Member over 10 years ago
Tomato is a berry if speaking botanically. In cooking, a plant is fruit if sweet and vegetable if savory so everyone is right.
sbchamp over 10 years ago
Just cuz we don’t buy ’em…
sterling3 Premium Member over 10 years ago
Go to The French Laundry
YatInExile over 10 years ago
There’s a place outside New Orleans that sells pickle snowballs. Pickle juice on shaved ice and on request, they’ll add a big pickle to it.
* In New Orleans, we call ’em snowballs.
RickMK over 10 years ago
It depends on who gets to decide the meanings of the words: botanists or everybody else. Why should they get to decide on the definitions of words in the English language? That’s the job of dictionaries, not scientists!
I say a tomato is a vegetable because that’s the way the word is used in the English language. Let scientists use their own jargon however they want, but don’t make me use the definitions they’ve made up for their own use.
bobdingus over 10 years ago
Technically, any part of the plant that contains the seeds is a fruit. Tomatoes are fruit, as are cucumbers, pumpkins, corn cobs, etc. Technically, a vegetable is any food that comes from a plants. Therefore a tomato and all of the above are both fruit and vegetable.
Dragoncat over 10 years ago
A smart person knows that a tomato is a fruit. A wise person knows not to add it to a fruit salad.
Ink blot Premium Member over 10 years ago
Set aside your political leanings for a moment — as well as the unproductive fruit/vegetable argument. If you look up the nutritional value of ketchup, you will see that it has plenty of nutritional value. Not as much as tomato soup, perhaps, but more than some vegetables that you wouldn’t scoff at. It makes perfect sense to count the nutritional contribution of ketchup as part of the nutritional value of the whole meal. -BTW, here’s a link to the best (free) website on food nutrition facts that I’ve ever found on-line:-http://nutritiondata.self.com/facts/vegetables-and-vegetable-products/3015/2
hippogriff over 10 years ago
JPuzzleWhiz: Watermelon, all gourds (squash, etc.), pumpkin, some beans,
platechick over 10 years ago
Cuz…..yuck!
markjoseph125 over 10 years ago
Superb reading: Tomatoland by Barry Estabrook.