I buy creamy to make my Peanut Butter Balls. For everything else, I buy chunky. It is great on my PB&J sandwiches, or on a spoon straight out of the jar, or even on toast.
I’ve alway been a creamy peanut butter nutter. I was brought up on Skippy ( my Dad’s favorite ) but somewhere along the line switched to Jiff.
Here in Ecuador, jars of peanut butter are expensive and hard to find, but you can buy the fresh, homemade versions, in plastic bags and containers cheaply in the mercados ( open markets ). Very popular for cooking but differs from jarred peanut butter, because it doesn’t have the sugars, additives and oils added. It’s more like a peanut paste.
.
Just remember: Man cannot live by bread alone….he must have peanut butter !
I prefer chunky but have to buy plain because it sticks in my teeth and then I have to dig it out. It tastes the same but it’s not as satisfying. I also prefer whole berry cranberry sauce to the smooth kind.
Templo S.U.D. over 7 years ago
I don’t mind creamy PB or chunky PB, but I don’t like the PB that still has the peanut oil which you have to stir around.
dadoctah over 7 years ago
I have just one word to say to you, Earl.
Nutella.
J Short over 7 years ago
The decaf of peanut butter.
stewross603 over 7 years ago
Natural PB…Just leave it on pantry shelf for couple days…..no stirring needed.
GROG Premium Member over 7 years ago
Buying any kind of peanut butter is a ridiculous waste of money.
stewross603 over 7 years ago
Forgot to say “UPSIDE DOWN” for a couple days. No stirring required.
sfreader1 over 7 years ago
I buy creamy to make my Peanut Butter Balls. For everything else, I buy chunky. It is great on my PB&J sandwiches, or on a spoon straight out of the jar, or even on toast.
garcoa over 7 years ago
I feel the same way about OJ – buy it with the pulp.
Linguist over 7 years ago
I’ve alway been a creamy peanut butter nutter. I was brought up on Skippy ( my Dad’s favorite ) but somewhere along the line switched to Jiff.
Here in Ecuador, jars of peanut butter are expensive and hard to find, but you can buy the fresh, homemade versions, in plastic bags and containers cheaply in the mercados ( open markets ). Very popular for cooking but differs from jarred peanut butter, because it doesn’t have the sugars, additives and oils added. It’s more like a peanut paste.
.
Just remember: Man cannot live by bread alone….he must have peanut butter !
Queen of America over 7 years ago
I’m with Earl. Why, why, for all things holy, would anyone buy smooth peanut butter?
Perkycat over 7 years ago
I’m a chunky lover myself. I have it almost every morning on my bagel with honey and cinnamon.
jtviper7 over 7 years ago
I don’t like anything chunky…
More or Less Premium Member over 7 years ago
I despise food nazis. Just thought I’d mention it.
lagoulou over 7 years ago
I like my peanut butter whipped!
dutchs over 7 years ago
Or as I call it, “brown slime.” Just the smooth variety.
pcolli over 7 years ago
Peanut butter has to be chunky and contain the brown skins to be worthy of ending up in my cupboard.
1953Baby over 7 years ago
I had no idea that there were people who didn’t like peanut butter. . .Do they still make Peter Pan Peanut Butter?
1953Baby over 7 years ago
P.S. It IS the little things that can mar a relationship. . .course with Earl and Opal, there’s not much that doesn’t. . .
bossyheifer over 7 years ago
Peanut butter is like regular butter – smooth. If you want chunky, eat peanuts.
alondra over 7 years ago
I prefer chunky but have to buy plain because it sticks in my teeth and then I have to dig it out. It tastes the same but it’s not as satisfying. I also prefer whole berry cranberry sauce to the smooth kind.
Kirk Barnes Premium Member over 7 years ago
Real smooth, Earl.