Mr. Burke: No, you may not use your calculators. Girl: Why? Guess what we're doing: artisanal arithmetic! Frazz: Mr. Burke is good with math and words!
I use square root all the time. Just calculate a standard deviation without it. But the real reason it is useful is, it is trivial compared to the GOOD stuff – differential geometry, etc.
If nothing else, being able to round the numbers a bit and do a rough approximation in your head will save your butt when you hit the wrong key on the calculator. I run into this all the time in science classes—kids who have no “feel” for the numbers and don’t recognize that the result the calculator gave them is thoroughly absurd.
I was at Walmart yesterday. Proof people need to be able to do math in their head? One brand of sausage was $1.88 for a pound. The two pound economy size was $4.88…
I once tried to buy two candy bars that were three for a dollar. Neither the clerk nor the store manager was able to figure out that I owed 67 cents plus tax.
Taught mine to appreciate maths by bringing coins and asking him how many of each sort he needed to get his pocket money. Any error was his, if he asked too much he would be fined by that amount, if he asked too little… that’s why he should learn simple arithmetics. Strangely enough he now thanks me for it.
Back in the VCR days I was in Blockbuster when the computer that ran the registers wa down. The manager had given each clerk s paper with the total rental amont with tax. When I tried to buy a tape none of the clerks could figure out the 5% sales tax total. They wouldn’t take my word for 1.05 x price (5% sales tax).
Haha! Clinton could have used that in his speech the other night. It just might make basic math more appealing to those who like to get “creative” with numbers. ( Is this strip’s prescience expanding from weather to politics?)
I’m reminded of a Readers’ Digest item where the power went out at a fast food joint, took down all the trick registers. Kid behind the counter says, “Well, I guess we’ll have to do this the old-fashioned way,” and pulls a calculator from the till.
ealesef, you win the free Sasparella, if you can figure out who I am, and where I live, but I’m good for it! Good job…..I notice you’re the only one to answer the challenge…
GoNordrike over 12 years ago
I love the way Mr. Burke calls it, Artisanal Arithmetic! Maybe it can also be consider Old School Math?
Varnes over 12 years ago
Quick, third grade math question……What’s the difference between mean and mode…?
The Old Wolf over 12 years ago
“A feeling of power”!
wcorvi over 12 years ago
I use square root all the time. Just calculate a standard deviation without it. But the real reason it is useful is, it is trivial compared to the GOOD stuff – differential geometry, etc.
puddleglum1066 over 12 years ago
If nothing else, being able to round the numbers a bit and do a rough approximation in your head will save your butt when you hit the wrong key on the calculator. I run into this all the time in science classes—kids who have no “feel” for the numbers and don’t recognize that the result the calculator gave them is thoroughly absurd.
bagbalm over 12 years ago
I was at Walmart yesterday. Proof people need to be able to do math in their head? One brand of sausage was $1.88 for a pound. The two pound economy size was $4.88…
magicwalnut over 12 years ago
Isaac Asimov (I think) wrote a story about us winning a war with a secret weapon…a guy who could do arithmetic without a calculator.
kingstonave over 12 years ago
The unplugged version always rocks.
South2North over 12 years ago
Square roots by hand? “Synthetic Division” was apiece of cake compared to that!
South2North over 12 years ago
Try computing the diagonal of a rectangle without one – except for the 3-4-5 cases.
chaimsmom over 12 years ago
I once tried to buy two candy bars that were three for a dollar. Neither the clerk nor the store manager was able to figure out that I owed 67 cents plus tax.
cabalonrye over 12 years ago
Taught mine to appreciate maths by bringing coins and asking him how many of each sort he needed to get his pocket money. Any error was his, if he asked too much he would be fined by that amount, if he asked too little… that’s why he should learn simple arithmetics. Strangely enough he now thanks me for it.
Olddog1 over 12 years ago
Back in the VCR days I was in Blockbuster when the computer that ran the registers wa down. The manager had given each clerk s paper with the total rental amont with tax. When I tried to buy a tape none of the clerks could figure out the 5% sales tax total. They wouldn’t take my word for 1.05 x price (5% sales tax).
kc7vpj over 12 years ago
How about using a “slip stick?” How many can still use one or for that matter has one?
Varnes over 12 years ago
neatslob, got me! Soputh2North, might as well throw in average, too, although I understand that…..
Arianne over 12 years ago
Haha! Clinton could have used that in his speech the other night. It just might make basic math more appealing to those who like to get “creative” with numbers. ( Is this strip’s prescience expanding from weather to politics?)
danketaz Premium Member over 12 years ago
Who wouldn’t like to be as smart as their calculator?
K M over 12 years ago
I’m reminded of a Readers’ Digest item where the power went out at a fast food joint, took down all the trick registers. Kid behind the counter says, “Well, I guess we’ll have to do this the old-fashioned way,” and pulls a calculator from the till.
Varnes over 12 years ago
ealesef, you win the free Sasparella, if you can figure out who I am, and where I live, but I’m good for it! Good job…..I notice you’re the only one to answer the challenge…
Michelle Morris over 12 years ago
COOLEST. THING. EVER!