When their kids were little, my brother and his wife altered the whole story of Little Red Riding Hood, not just the ending. They felt it was unfair to wolves that they were always portrayed as the bad guys in children’s stories. They believed that no animal is worse than any other.
I only censored one story in my life, a French tale, Mr Seguin’s goat. It ends badly as the goat dies after fighting the wolf all night long. My nephew and niece were a little too small for that kind of story so I changed the ending. When they were older I told the real story.
Is she reading him “Hamster Huey and the Gooey Kablooie”? (When Calvin’s dad made some editorial changes to that book, the strip ended with Hobbes wondering if the townsfolk would ever find Hamster Huey’s head.)
I don’t remember many of the fairy tales from my youth. But some I think were designed to scare children into being good. Whatever works IMO. We don’t all respond to higher level motivation.
I read some of the books assigned to my kiddo when she was in middle school. I wasn’t particularly fond of them and it gave me a chance to talk about them with her. I loved bed time stories. We continued that up until she got to middle school. Stories, of course, became more advanced as she got older. In the end we were sharing novels at bedtime, one chapter at a time.
My friend is an active grammy, and we were talking about the books available to kids today. Check out the “lit” board books for toddlers at Amazon (just to see what some are “hawking.” There’s a “Classic Baby Lit Collection set” that includes, Pride and Prejudice, Romeo and Juliet, Sherlock Holmes, Moby Dick, Jane Eyre, Alice in Wonderland, Jungle Book, and the Wizard of Oz. Talk about a mixed bag. . .
I think it’s a perfect idea to “alter” what you’re reading to a child to reflect your own personal biases and to possibly avoid “improper” thoughts or nightmares. That is, after all, what T.T.A.G. William Barr is doing for republicans and the rest of America vis-à-vis the Mueller Report (such a “caring” and “thoughtful” person.) /s
Farside99 over 5 years ago
She doesn’t want to start graphic nightmares at this age. He’ll get them soon enough.
Purple People Eater over 5 years ago
When their kids were little, my brother and his wife altered the whole story of Little Red Riding Hood, not just the ending. They felt it was unfair to wolves that they were always portrayed as the bad guys in children’s stories. They believed that no animal is worse than any other.
cubswin2016 over 5 years ago
It is too bad there are not more parents like this.
Kwen over 5 years ago
I want to listen to Vicky’s bedtime stories!
contralto2b over 5 years ago
I used to read to my mother when she was was working on her quilts/afghans/etc. I would censor them (but not change them).
cabalonrye over 5 years ago
I only censored one story in my life, a French tale, Mr Seguin’s goat. It ends badly as the goat dies after fighting the wolf all night long. My nephew and niece were a little too small for that kind of story so I changed the ending. When they were older I told the real story.
jagedlo over 5 years ago
love when they put the little heart of love above Pasquale!
dadoctah over 5 years ago
Is she reading him “Hamster Huey and the Gooey Kablooie”? (When Calvin’s dad made some editorial changes to that book, the strip ended with Hobbes wondering if the townsfolk would ever find Hamster Huey’s head.)
sandpiper over 5 years ago
Depends on the story. With some, one revises at risk of being told, That’s not the way it goes., as children remember more than we think
jvn over 5 years ago
What is she reading to him? Stephen King’s “It”?
rshive over 5 years ago
I don’t remember many of the fairy tales from my youth. But some I think were designed to scare children into being good. Whatever works IMO. We don’t all respond to higher level motivation.
car2ner over 5 years ago
I read some of the books assigned to my kiddo when she was in middle school. I wasn’t particularly fond of them and it gave me a chance to talk about them with her. I loved bed time stories. We continued that up until she got to middle school. Stories, of course, became more advanced as she got older. In the end we were sharing novels at bedtime, one chapter at a time.
1953Baby over 5 years ago
My friend is an active grammy, and we were talking about the books available to kids today. Check out the “lit” board books for toddlers at Amazon (just to see what some are “hawking.” There’s a “Classic Baby Lit Collection set” that includes, Pride and Prejudice, Romeo and Juliet, Sherlock Holmes, Moby Dick, Jane Eyre, Alice in Wonderland, Jungle Book, and the Wizard of Oz. Talk about a mixed bag. . .
DCBakerEsq over 5 years ago
… and they all lived a moderately happy life for an appropriate amount of time thereafter. The end.
jbarnes over 5 years ago
I like to change endings to “they all lived happily and had many more adventures”
dragonbite over 5 years ago
I altered stories all the time.. and usually the kids would call me on it!
KevDoneIt over 5 years ago
Tell that to the guy who thought he could live with the polar bears
wellis1947 Premium Member over 5 years ago
I think it’s a perfect idea to “alter” what you’re reading to a child to reflect your own personal biases and to possibly avoid “improper” thoughts or nightmares. That is, after all, what T.T.A.G. William Barr is doing for republicans and the rest of America vis-à-vis the Mueller Report (such a “caring” and “thoughtful” person.) /s
bakana over 5 years ago
Just watch out when Vickie takes over the Editing duties.
hagarthehorrible over 5 years ago
The competent authorities, parents and grandparents, have all the copyright to the story’s ending.