OK – for all of you who claim the Bible is factual: According to the “evidence” in the gospels (returning to Bethlehem for the census, etc.), if Yehoshua ben Yosef (your guy’s actual name) was, in fact, born (which is by no means a sure thing), it was in June. The December 25 thing was announced to help force Northern Europeans into Catholicism by co-opting their existing Winter Solstice rites – gifts, decorated trees, etc. And I realize that a tendency to believe that poorly-written fiction is history could well correlate with a belief that the stars move around a geocentric sky, but that is just not the case.
You can add to that the fact that there are at least 5 other traditions featuring sun gods born around the Winter Solstice, then killed & resurrected around the Vernal Equinox – and all of them predate Christian mythology. So not only is it bad fiction, it’s plagiarized bad fiction.
Ratkin Premium Member about 2 years ago
and a stable place to settle down.
Jesy Bertz Premium Member about 2 years ago
You need to speak to the Manger.
iggyman about 2 years ago
Silent Night!
Doug K about 2 years ago
They don’t even need that star – it’s more for some other guys.
Besides she brought (is carrying) the real Star with her.
gopher gofer about 2 years ago
there was a pregnant pause before she replied…
Little Caesar about 2 years ago
Give Tom Bodett a call. He’ll leave the light on for you.
uniquename about 2 years ago
One star. The highest rating ever.
More Coffee Please! Premium Member about 2 years ago
Good one.
Zebrastripes about 2 years ago
Star light, star bright…..
ComicLover2 Premium Member about 2 years ago
Nice
P51Strega about 2 years ago
Yule be fine.
Cozmik Cowboy about 2 years ago
OK – for all of you who claim the Bible is factual: According to the “evidence” in the gospels (returning to Bethlehem for the census, etc.), if Yehoshua ben Yosef (your guy’s actual name) was, in fact, born (which is by no means a sure thing), it was in June. The December 25 thing was announced to help force Northern Europeans into Catholicism by co-opting their existing Winter Solstice rites – gifts, decorated trees, etc. And I realize that a tendency to believe that poorly-written fiction is history could well correlate with a belief that the stars move around a geocentric sky, but that is just not the case.
You can add to that the fact that there are at least 5 other traditions featuring sun gods born around the Winter Solstice, then killed & resurrected around the Vernal Equinox – and all of them predate Christian mythology. So not only is it bad fiction, it’s plagiarized bad fiction.
sedrelwesley2 Premium Member about 2 years ago
Not biblically accurate (doesn’t mean it couldn’t be true.)
sisterea about 2 years ago
Merry Christmas everyone
figuratively speaking about 2 years ago
That’s all we need.
Odd Dog Premium Member about 2 years ago
Merry Christmas to all who observe and happy holidays and best wish’s to those that observe something else!
Lablubber about 2 years ago
Someones been making Mary. (I know. I’ll let myself out.)
paullp Premium Member about 2 years ago
At this time of year, I enjoy rereading The Star, a classic science fiction tale by Arthur C. Clarke.
bucknsuzie about 2 years ago
Nobody cares tonight.
6turtle9 about 2 years ago
Hopefully the Falafel Hut delivers.