Not on an archaeological dig, you haven’t! It’s not THAT old! -Maybe cleaning out a hoarder’s attic, or hidden in the bottom of a suitcase donated to the Goodwill…
Yes, you do need time to pass before something is regarded as a classic, no question. But archaeological expeditions are for much, much earlier time periods, and often into time periods where there is either no written record (and the information comes from potshards, ruins of buildings and skeletons), or, if a written record is found, further research is needed to understand the language…
how ironic that just recently a lost manuscript to to kill a mockingbird was just found written by harper lee..it was actually written before to kill a mockingbird but never published..it is about an adult scout finch returning to Alabama to visit her father..it is to be published soon..
Phylum, it was never lost. Harper Lee has always known where it was—she was persuaded to rework it for publication, even though she is mostly deaf, blind, and confined to a wheelchair in assisted living. Kudos to her!
I will admit that many of the classics assigned in high school were difficult, but try going back, you may find that you have matured enough to understand what classic really is.Styles pf writing do change, but good solid story telling is good solid story telling.
I read “Animal Farm” in my 20s for fun. Never had to read it in school. I love the line, “all are created equal, but some are more equal than others”. The one sentence tells all why communism cannot work in a society where mankind is a part.
I don’t know why Harper Lee would release another book at this point in her life. She has had the status of revered literary idol for decades. The new novel will be merciless analyzed and compared to TKAM.
Ever read a new book and judged it to be a future classic? I have. Ender’s Game was that way, as was Stranger in a Strange Land, Startide Rising, Rainbow’s End, and Ready Player One. Author’s names omitted on purpose.
Well, as long as Time is not a factor; going from somewhere in bc to the 20th; something enduring. How early in ‘antiquity’ did they lay bricks that way?
My son, who’s currently in high school, is being subjected to all the same stuff I had to read 40 years ago: Great Gatsby, Lord of the Flies (my least favorite book ever), 1984, and even Moby Dick. It’s like his English teachers are only teaching what they were subjected to by their own English teachers.
Some of the comments made here today are very sad indeed. I get that many of you are not avid readers, but I very much doubt that you would be reading more and making better choices about what you read today if only your teachers in high school or college had assigned different books.
I remember hating Lord of the Flies in high school. I reread it when I was in my late 30s and was blown away. There’s so much there that is verboten discussion in a HS classroom. It’s a poor choice for that age group.
This is a perfect test to see if someone has grounds to sue their school for fraud: If they cannot read and understand such as ‘To Kill A Mockingbird’ then they either ignorant, or illiterate, or both.
http://liquor.com/recipes/tequila-mockingbird/Alternate recipe: substitute vodka and a cigarette butt for the tequila.And now you know what I think of tequila.
argythree: There is a field called industrial archeology exploring industrial revolution period. For instance, it was discovered that slaves were paid and what wasn’t taken back by the predecessor of thee company store, could be saved to buy their freedom when they were too old to be productive any more. So much for the kind-hearted owner taking care of elderly slaves!
felinefan55: Communism does work – in voluntary associations such as Israeli Kibbutzim, Tanzanian Ujimaa, North American Hutterite communities, etc. It just can’t work for entire nations. “From each according to their ability, to each according to their need” works fine until you get someone who will take what they need but not contribute what they can. In the voluntary group, you say “bye bye” and that solves it. On a national level, you have to invoke the legal code, and that rapidly makes the system a tyranny because no other country wants them either and those making the judgement are intrinsically too powerful.
The ideal “family sharing” image comes awfully close to communism. What’s the difference? the intent? the relationships? the fact that mom and dad’s dictatorship is assumed rather than overt?
I just went through all the comments…. and I want to say thank you. Everyone that mentioned a title or author – you have expanded my list of stories, books, authorsSummer’s coming. My reading list has suddenly expanded.
Argythree almost 10 years ago
Not on an archaeological dig, you haven’t! It’s not THAT old! -Maybe cleaning out a hoarder’s attic, or hidden in the bottom of a suitcase donated to the Goodwill…
Ida No almost 10 years ago
Archeologist Two: “How many does that make it now?”
Argythree almost 10 years ago
Yes, you do need time to pass before something is regarded as a classic, no question. But archaeological expeditions are for much, much earlier time periods, and often into time periods where there is either no written record (and the information comes from potshards, ruins of buildings and skeletons), or, if a written record is found, further research is needed to understand the language…
Superfrog almost 10 years ago
Nice to see that it’s a tablet edition.
phylum almost 10 years ago
how ironic that just recently a lost manuscript to to kill a mockingbird was just found written by harper lee..it was actually written before to kill a mockingbird but never published..it is about an adult scout finch returning to Alabama to visit her father..it is to be published soon..
phylum almost 10 years ago
sorry college freshmen…but I cant wait…
Kim Roberts almost 10 years ago
Phylum, it was never lost. Harper Lee has always known where it was—she was persuaded to rework it for publication, even though she is mostly deaf, blind, and confined to a wheelchair in assisted living. Kudos to her!
puddlesplatt almost 10 years ago
451 scared the heck out of me.
Varnes almost 10 years ago
Superfrog, excellent…The Snow Fly, Joseph Heywood, Jimi Hendrix Turns 80, Tim Sandlin….
Can't Sleep almost 10 years ago
Given the age of the tablet, shouldn’t that be a prequel?
twhalen almost 10 years ago
Perhaps Nabuquduriuzhur thought that Atticus Finch was wrong to defend Tom Robinson and that social justice wasn’t necessary in the Jim Crow South.
A Martin almost 10 years ago
I will admit that many of the classics assigned in high school were difficult, but try going back, you may find that you have matured enough to understand what classic really is.Styles pf writing do change, but good solid story telling is good solid story telling.
vwdualnomand almost 10 years ago
freshman english nightmare…..
William Bednar Premium Member almost 10 years ago
Yep. The papyrus was titled: To Kill a Vulture.
felinefan55 Premium Member almost 10 years ago
I read “Animal Farm” in my 20s for fun. Never had to read it in school. I love the line, “all are created equal, but some are more equal than others”. The one sentence tells all why communism cannot work in a society where mankind is a part.
felinefan55 Premium Member almost 10 years ago
Also read “Watership Down” around that time. I am surprised it’s considered a “children’s book”. I recall it being quite bloody.
Honorable Mention In The Banjo Toss Premium Member almost 10 years ago
I don’t know why Harper Lee would release another book at this point in her life. She has had the status of revered literary idol for decades. The new novel will be merciless analyzed and compared to TKAM.
palos almost 10 years ago
And I thought he found Commandments XI to XV.
Vonne Anton almost 10 years ago
Ever read a new book and judged it to be a future classic? I have. Ender’s Game was that way, as was Stranger in a Strange Land, Startide Rising, Rainbow’s End, and Ready Player One. Author’s names omitted on purpose.
dabugger almost 10 years ago
Well, as long as Time is not a factor; going from somewhere in bc to the 20th; something enduring. How early in ‘antiquity’ did they lay bricks that way?
pshapley Premium Member almost 10 years ago
My son, who’s currently in high school, is being subjected to all the same stuff I had to read 40 years ago: Great Gatsby, Lord of the Flies (my least favorite book ever), 1984, and even Moby Dick. It’s like his English teachers are only teaching what they were subjected to by their own English teachers.
William Neal McPheeters almost 10 years ago
Some of the comments made here today are very sad indeed. I get that many of you are not avid readers, but I very much doubt that you would be reading more and making better choices about what you read today if only your teachers in high school or college had assigned different books.
Diane in comics land Premium Member almost 10 years ago
I remember hating Lord of the Flies in high school. I reread it when I was in my late 30s and was blown away. There’s so much there that is verboten discussion in a HS classroom. It’s a poor choice for that age group.
Reppr Premium Member almost 10 years ago
I wonder what else is down there….Jimmy Hoffa…Rose Law Firm billing records….could be anything.
Varnes almost 10 years ago
Vonne, “The Snow Fly” Tell me that isn’t a classic. It invents a whole new metaphor for life …
didereaux almost 10 years ago
This is a perfect test to see if someone has grounds to sue their school for fraud: If they cannot read and understand such as ‘To Kill A Mockingbird’ then they either ignorant, or illiterate, or both.
tired-one almost 10 years ago
http://liquor.com/recipes/tequila-mockingbird/Alternate recipe: substitute vodka and a cigarette butt for the tequila.And now you know what I think of tequila.
hippogriff almost 10 years ago
argythree: There is a field called industrial archeology exploring industrial revolution period. For instance, it was discovered that slaves were paid and what wasn’t taken back by the predecessor of thee company store, could be saved to buy their freedom when they were too old to be productive any more. So much for the kind-hearted owner taking care of elderly slaves!
Arianne almost 10 years ago
At first glance, it looks to be quite dirty.
smadanek almost 10 years ago
Is there an “electric sheep” app for Android? Definitely not for IOS
smadanek almost 10 years ago
Oops there is an electric sheep app and it also works on IoS
Kveldulf almost 10 years ago
Pretty much the only type of slave not to exist was the slave who wanted to be a slave.
Kevin Roth Premium Member almost 10 years ago
Aww, come on. Ms. Lee isn’t THAT old. O.o
hippogriff almost 10 years ago
felinefan55: Communism does work – in voluntary associations such as Israeli Kibbutzim, Tanzanian Ujimaa, North American Hutterite communities, etc. It just can’t work for entire nations. “From each according to their ability, to each according to their need” works fine until you get someone who will take what they need but not contribute what they can. In the voluntary group, you say “bye bye” and that solves it. On a national level, you have to invoke the legal code, and that rapidly makes the system a tyranny because no other country wants them either and those making the judgement are intrinsically too powerful.
DutchUncle almost 10 years ago
The ideal “family sharing” image comes awfully close to communism. What’s the difference? the intent? the relationships? the fact that mom and dad’s dictatorship is assumed rather than overt?
Hunter7 almost 10 years ago
I just went through all the comments…. and I want to say thank you. Everyone that mentioned a title or author – you have expanded my list of stories, books, authorsSummer’s coming. My reading list has suddenly expanded.