Dylan’s Nobel is pretty much right in line with previous awards. They’ve always been more about social-political statements than about quality writing. I mean, come on! Saul Bellow? Naguib Mahfouz? Really?
Since Scottish things/people have been mentioned, if I ever get together with a bunch of rancid hippies and form a street gang, I’d call it “aft a-gley.”
False premise. Bob Dylan is not the first songwriter to win the Noble prize in literature. That honor belongs to the poet and songwriter Rabindranath Tagore, who was honored in 1913. He wrote the national anthems of both India and Bangladesh, as well as over a hundred other songs, many of which are still sung and recorded today. Fair is fair, he won the Nobel for a book of poetry (which he originally published in Bengali and then translated into English himself), and not for his songwriting, so maybe I’m splitting hairs, but I’m really tired of that falsehood about Bob Dylan’s being “the first.”
Actually, they were Swedish hippies. But I suppose that’s kinda the same thing.
The real point is not Dylan at all, but that there are so many worthy potential candidates not considered at all. Seems like catering to PopCult. And I’m not a cultist (unless you consider following Frog Applause a “cult.” Would that make Sister Teresa a Cult Leader? Would that be a Bad Thing?)….
Meh~tdology, fka Pepelaputr over 6 years ago
Perhaps they thought he was Dylan Thomas.
(Whoever HE was…)
Baslim the Beggar Premium Member over 6 years ago
So a Welsh is a Scot?
Cheer up, Mr, Welsh, the Swedish Academy is just warming up for the presentation to ABBA…
And then maybe Björk?
waycyber over 6 years ago
I love his work
Dylan, Dylan, DylanDylanDylan, Dylan Dylaaan
painedsmile over 6 years ago
How did this Welch guy know my prostate is rancid? I don’t remember him tasting it. As for being a hippie, I’m not old enough.
painedsmile over 6 years ago
I didn’t realize that song lyrics were considered literature. When, if ever, will comics be considered literature?
victor12341234 over 6 years ago
I love Dylan..if he reads this, O I will never wash my prostate again.
Arianne over 6 years ago
Oh, come on… the millennials aren’t that bad…
Say What Now‽ Premium Member over 6 years ago
How many trains must a man spot before you can call him a man?
Brass Orchid Premium Member over 6 years ago
Hmm… not a Dylan fan then?
coltish1 over 6 years ago
Dylan’s Nobel is pretty much right in line with previous awards. They’ve always been more about social-political statements than about quality writing. I mean, come on! Saul Bellow? Naguib Mahfouz? Really?
garrodwilbur over 6 years ago
To bad@@@Dylan would be pissed with you
Rotifer FREE BEER & BATH MATS ON FEB. 31st Thalweg Premium Member over 6 years ago
The Rancid Prostates would a good name for the Frog Applause™ house band (if Frog Applause™ had a house band).
Happy, happy, happy!!! Premium Member over 6 years ago
…who?
Teto85 Premium Member over 6 years ago
Mr Welsh needs to listen to some Dylan. Particularly the one about how everybody must get stoned.
Radish... over 6 years ago
Striking for the gentle, striking for the kind
Striking for the guardians and protectors of the mind
An’ the poet and the painter far behind his rightful time
An’ we gazed upon the chimes of freedom flashing
.
Bob Dylan
gigagrouch over 6 years ago
Well, i tend to agree with my cousin that the Bob is overrated. But i do take issue with his views on hippies…
Larry Miller Premium Member over 6 years ago
Since Scottish things/people have been mentioned, if I ever get together with a bunch of rancid hippies and form a street gang, I’d call it “aft a-gley.”
Howard'sMyHero over 6 years ago
This is “All Cloudy With A Chance Of Swedish Meatballs” … but, alas, I hear they’re from Turkey ….
William Neal McPheeters over 6 years ago
You don’t need a weather man To know which way the wind blows.
Linguist over 6 years ago
" And death shall have no dominion
.Dead man naked they shall be one
With the man in the wind and the west moon;
<When their bones are picked clean
and the clean bones gone,
They shall have stars at elbow and foot;
Though they go mad they shall be sane,
Though they sink through the sea they shall rise again;
Though lovers be lost love shall not;
And death shall have no dominion…."
.
And Death Shall Have No Dominion
– Poem by Dylan Thomas
hmofo813 Premium Member over 6 years ago
False premise. Bob Dylan is not the first songwriter to win the Noble prize in literature. That honor belongs to the poet and songwriter Rabindranath Tagore, who was honored in 1913. He wrote the national anthems of both India and Bangladesh, as well as over a hundred other songs, many of which are still sung and recorded today. Fair is fair, he won the Nobel for a book of poetry (which he originally published in Bengali and then translated into English himself), and not for his songwriting, so maybe I’m splitting hairs, but I’m really tired of that falsehood about Bob Dylan’s being “the first.”
willie_mctell over 6 years ago
The quote ranks right up there with “colonized by a nation of wankers.” Welsh is more than all right in my book.
Sisyphos over 6 years ago
Actually, they were Swedish hippies. But I suppose that’s kinda the same thing.
The real point is not Dylan at all, but that there are so many worthy potential candidates not considered at all. Seems like catering to PopCult. And I’m not a cultist (unless you consider following Frog Applause a “cult.” Would that make Sister Teresa a Cult Leader? Would that be a Bad Thing?)….
Radish... over 6 years ago
Who would get the first Froglandia, No Cow Bell award?
INGSOC over 6 years ago
Minutemen – Bob Dylan Wrote Propaganda Songs • https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Bmg-WDSEzgA