Were I Charlie Brown, I’d drop those friends like a bad habit. They planned a “testimonial dinner” in his honor then dropped out at the last minute because they felt that holding one was hypocritical. What they did in the end was the epitome of cruelty.
How remarkable!! This is the one and only time that we see Patty and Peppermint Patty standing in each other’s vicinity in the whole history of the strip. It’s just a shame that Schulz doesn’t show them interacting with each other in any way, which leads me to wonder whether the two girls even know each other. What do readers think?
There was nothing hypocritical about it. They were (or could have been) honoring his effort, his dedication to the team and the sport and his tenacity, his love for baseball.
It’s easy to honor a winner, even one that wins a world series once every 50 years. It’s much harder (and character building) for someone with Charlie Brown’s record to keep playing the game, keep organizing a team and not just quit and go home.
Maybe you’re not hypocrital, but all of you are really selfish, you only think about how bad this will feel for you, but you don’t think about Charie Brown’s feelings.
They could’ve just said the truth, what motivated them to have the dinner in the first place. They wanted to do something nice. You don’t have to be insincere to be kind.
You know how you’d see headlines about Sparky like “The Suprising Dark Side of America’s Favorite Cartoonist”? I think of story lines like this and then I read those headlines and I just can’t stop laughing. Did any of these people actually READ Peanuts?!?
I never thought less of Charlie Brown’s friends than I did when I saw this. They set up a situation to honor him, then go out of their way to humiliate him. I’m glad Woodstock stuck with him, at least.
I’ve noticed that CSchulz had somewhat of a mean streak to his humor. Bashing CB all the time, the verbal abuse to CB in all the tv specials, and the dark personality of Lucy. The real scary part is the readers who laugh and find humor in the abuse of another – even a cartoon character.
Man, I grew up with Peanuts. How did I not understand the cruelty? Sort of like going back and re-reading Calvin and Hobbes…Calvin is a jumbo jerk. Reading the Charles Shultz Bio is recommended reading to understand….
No offense to the memory of Sparky, but this is total BS. Everyone is already there and they THEN decide to cancel?! Sheesh. I still love Peanuts though.
When you consider that Sparky wrote Charlie Brown as an autobiographical character, what must he have suffered to be able to create this type of strip?
And, oh, by the way, who didn’t see this coming 2 weeks ago?
You know what’s hypocritical, Linus? You never sticking up for Charlie Brown when people are bullying him, but it’s okay to stand up for some girl when people are bullying her! Granted, said girl was in a bad state, but you’re supposed to be Chuck’s best buddy!
Face it, Charlie Brown. It’s not you, it’s them. As soon as you graduate high school, at age 18, volunteer for the U.S. Air Force. There, you will find all the brothers and sisters you will ever need. Never look back! Never go back!
Even after Charlie Brown gave everyone he knows a Valentine’s Day card, he only got a pity Valentine card, from Patty, who wrote over a card she had received.
At least Woodstock stayed. And it’s hypocritical of Linus to get everyone to throw the party for Charlie Brown and then leave when everyone else backs out.
Even worse than everyone complaining the dinner would be hypocritical and should be cancelled is they’re doing within earshot of poor ol’ Charlie Brown.
The lack of sincerity would be detrimental to Linus’s Great Pumpkin theological viewpoint. The Great one only appears over the most sincere pumpkin patch.
He puts his heart into the team and he makes it possible for them to play. Everyone already knows they always lose but he is managing and pitching for the love of the game…that deserves a dinner! Let the testimony of the testimonial reflect his commitment
Asharah almost 5 years ago
POOR CHARLIE BROWN!!!!!
RedNeckHillbilly1778 almost 5 years ago
Ouch
Baarorso almost 5 years ago
Were I Charlie Brown, I’d drop those friends like a bad habit. They planned a “testimonial dinner” in his honor then dropped out at the last minute because they felt that holding one was hypocritical. What they did in the end was the epitome of cruelty.
Sonic the Hedgehog. almost 5 years ago
At least Woodstocks there
JoanHelen almost 5 years ago
Really, really sad. :(
Templo S.U.D. almost 5 years ago
now Joe Shlabotnik will want his money back
wjones almost 5 years ago
At least they could have had the diner without the testimonial.
Marblemouth almost 5 years ago
Were they going to serve more than toast?
Yngvar Følling almost 5 years ago
Think of it this way: this dinner with all the hypocritical praise would be great practice for getting into politics.
su43dipta almost 5 years ago
Linus, you’re being a snob more than a good friend. I don’t think I like you anymore!
hariseldon59 almost 5 years ago
A rare strip with Peppermint Patty and the original Patty in the same panel.
!!ǝlɐ⅁ almost 5 years ago
Charlie Brown, it could be worse. It could be hippocritical.
jpayne4040 almost 5 years ago
I’m surprised that Linus would be the one to cancel the dinner. I expected him to be the only holdout. Instead, the lone holdout is Woodstock!
jpayne4040 almost 5 years ago
I would never, ever, speak to or do anything with any of these kids ever again!
basspro almost 5 years ago
One of the worst comics there is, always has been.
Trond Sätre Premium Member almost 5 years ago
To paraphrase a classic line: Of all the Charlie Brown moments in the world, this is the Charlie Browniest… :-(
Hazelnut King almost 5 years ago
How remarkable!! This is the one and only time that we see Patty and Peppermint Patty standing in each other’s vicinity in the whole history of the strip. It’s just a shame that Schulz doesn’t show them interacting with each other in any way, which leads me to wonder whether the two girls even know each other. What do readers think?
mgl179 almost 5 years ago
There was nothing hypocritical about it. They were (or could have been) honoring his effort, his dedication to the team and the sport and his tenacity, his love for baseball.
It’s easy to honor a winner, even one that wins a world series once every 50 years. It’s much harder (and character building) for someone with Charlie Brown’s record to keep playing the game, keep organizing a team and not just quit and go home.
jagedlo almost 5 years ago
Said it yesterday and say it again today…“With ‘friends’ like this, who needs enemies?”
wesleylscott1 almost 5 years ago
Alone Again, Naturally…..
mjb515 almost 5 years ago
You were already past the point of no return there.
jrankin1959 almost 5 years ago
It’s probably just as well… knowing Lucy, she’d have turned it into a roast anyway.
Ellis97 almost 5 years ago
Some friends you turned out to be! Leaving poor Chuck all alone! Can’t you just do something nice for Charlie Brown, just because?
Neo Stryder almost 5 years ago
Maybe you’re not hypocrital, but all of you are really selfish, you only think about how bad this will feel for you, but you don’t think about Charie Brown’s feelings.
mrsdonaldson almost 5 years ago
They could’ve just said the truth, what motivated them to have the dinner in the first place. They wanted to do something nice. You don’t have to be insincere to be kind.
SusieB almost 5 years ago
Happy Valentine’s day Charlie Brown!
dwdl21 almost 5 years ago
You know? I love this comic but as stated if I were Charlie Brown I’d tell them all to take a hike!!
Penny Lane Premium Member almost 5 years ago
Et tu, Linus?
Tallguy almost 5 years ago
You know how you’d see headlines about Sparky like “The Suprising Dark Side of America’s Favorite Cartoonist”? I think of story lines like this and then I read those headlines and I just can’t stop laughing. Did any of these people actually READ Peanuts?!?
Dean almost 5 years ago
Any excuse for a party, unless being stuck with the bill because he is the only one left there.
Pointspread almost 5 years ago
Schultz you cruel &@$#%¥€!
hagarthehorrible almost 5 years ago
The friends have failed to appreciate the leader who might not be very skilful but there was no dearth of sincerity on his part to lead the team.
dv1093 almost 5 years ago
Yeah, I agree with both of you. 1. It’s only a comic, but 2. It’s not funny.
Robert Nowall Premium Member almost 5 years ago
I never thought less of Charlie Brown’s friends than I did when I saw this. They set up a situation to honor him, then go out of their way to humiliate him. I’m glad Woodstock stuck with him, at least.
dv1093 almost 5 years ago
I’ve noticed that CSchulz had somewhat of a mean streak to his humor. Bashing CB all the time, the verbal abuse to CB in all the tv specials, and the dark personality of Lucy. The real scary part is the readers who laugh and find humor in the abuse of another – even a cartoon character.
robcarroll1213 almost 5 years ago
Did Charles M. Schultz think this was funny?
Saddenedby Premium Member almost 5 years ago
me to Charlie Brown – it only hurts for a little while – that’s what they tell me – that’s what they say
Shinrinder Premium Member almost 5 years ago
Man, I grew up with Peanuts. How did I not understand the cruelty? Sort of like going back and re-reading Calvin and Hobbes…Calvin is a jumbo jerk. Reading the Charles Shultz Bio is recommended reading to understand….
Cary Rodda Premium Member almost 5 years ago
No offense to the memory of Sparky, but this is total BS. Everyone is already there and they THEN decide to cancel?! Sheesh. I still love Peanuts though.
karlykru Premium Member almost 5 years ago
Comics are often a reflection of real life or experience of the cartoonist – camouflaged in “humor”.
Darryl Heine almost 5 years ago
Poor Charlie Brown, Happy Valentine’s Day anyway…
drds2 almost 5 years ago
Heartbreakingly real for many people.
[Unnamed Reader - c603d1] almost 5 years ago
Charlie Brown is rarely (ever?) placed in happy situations, but this is about the most heartbreaking I’ve ever seen
marilynnbyerly almost 5 years ago
Let’s grab Charlie and take him to a friendly cartoon where people will be kind to him and appreciate him. Any suggestions?
Jan C almost 5 years ago
When you consider that Sparky wrote Charlie Brown as an autobiographical character, what must he have suffered to be able to create this type of strip?
And, oh, by the way, who didn’t see this coming 2 weeks ago?
Ellis97 almost 5 years ago
You know what’s hypocritical, Linus? You never sticking up for Charlie Brown when people are bullying him, but it’s okay to stand up for some girl when people are bullying her! Granted, said girl was in a bad state, but you’re supposed to be Chuck’s best buddy!
w2lj almost 5 years ago
Good ol’ Woodstock.
Ceeg22 Premium Member almost 5 years ago
I never expected Linus to be an
MrTerry1946 almost 5 years ago
this is a part of this comic strip i find very distasteful. good hearted Charlie gets bashed too often.
wingrest almost 5 years ago
the same as her holding the football and puling it the last second
SpongebobPatrickBackwards almost 5 years ago
It looks like Lucy came around.
SpongebobPatrickBackwards almost 5 years ago
HAHAHAHA
Liam Astle Premium Member almost 5 years ago
Linus obviously doesn’t know what a roast is.
PaulLeckner almost 5 years ago
Face it, Charlie Brown. It’s not you, it’s them. As soon as you graduate high school, at age 18, volunteer for the U.S. Air Force. There, you will find all the brothers and sisters you will ever need. Never look back! Never go back!
PaulLeckner almost 5 years ago
Even after Charlie Brown gave everyone he knows a Valentine’s Day card, he only got a pity Valentine card, from Patty, who wrote over a card she had received.
knight1192a almost 5 years ago
At least Woodstock stayed. And it’s hypocritical of Linus to get everyone to throw the party for Charlie Brown and then leave when everyone else backs out.
jbruins84341 almost 5 years ago
I thought Linus was supposed to be his best friend. Even he would be hypocritical? Some friend.
sparkle 13 Premium Member almost 5 years ago
This is GOOD Charlie !!! They left all the food !!!!1 lol
edonline almost 5 years ago
Even worse than everyone complaining the dinner would be hypocritical and should be cancelled is they’re doing within earshot of poor ol’ Charlie Brown.
Iwa Iniki almost 5 years ago
Charlie Brown is the best friend they all have. They just don’t realize it because they are all too selfish.
wesleylscott1 almost 5 years ago
The lack of sincerity would be detrimental to Linus’s Great Pumpkin theological viewpoint. The Great one only appears over the most sincere pumpkin patch.
Ellis97 almost 5 years ago
You guys are total blockheads!
ronaldspence almost 5 years ago
He puts his heart into the team and he makes it possible for them to play. Everyone already knows they always lose but he is managing and pitching for the love of the game…that deserves a dinner! Let the testimony of the testimonial reflect his commitment
Cameron1988 Premium Member almost 5 years ago
Kids are cruel
GreggW Premium Member almost 5 years ago
Guess the kids didn’t know that a lot of testimonial dinners are hypocritical.
[Unnamed Reader - b5d936] 2 months ago
charlie brown is a good manager, with a bad team