Oh those awful story problems! Often listed as “extra credit” on tests. I never did them (I have enough trouble with figures, thanks) and I always suspected she took points off for not doing them.
On the Peanuts Wiki site (https://peanuts.fandom.com/wiki/February_1974_comic_strips), if you hover your mouse over the description, it’ll give you the answer to the question…
There is an infinite number of answers that solve this problem. 7 dimes and 1 quarter works. As does 8 dimes and 2 quarters, and 50 dimes and 44 quarters. There just has to be 6 more dimes than quarters.
Any number of dimes and quarters where you have 6 fewer quarters than dimes will work:6 d and 0 q = 60 cents, flipped is 1.50. 90 cents more.10d and 4 q = 2 dollars, flipped is 2.90. 90 cents more. 15 d and 9 q = 3.75, flipped is 4.65. 90 cents more. etc. etc.There is not enough info to determine how may dimes and quarters he has.
The unwillingness many people show to the exercise of rigorous quantitative reasoning is why Las Vegas makes so much money, payday loan sharks are so successful, credit card companies can get away with predatory interest rates, and politicians can pass soak-the-poor tax laws.
I can relate. Currently, I’m having a really tough math unit, and it’s kinda getting on my nerves. I finally understand it now, but I hope that I can raise my grade a wee bit.
He would have 13 dimes and 7 quarters. Thirteen dimes plus seven quarters would equal 3.05 while 13 quarters (3.25) plus 7 dimes would be 3.95 and this concludes the boring math lesson for today.
I once called my wife in NY from a business convention in France. It was 3am there (9pm here), and I thought it was a good moment to catch her after dinner. I was also in high spirits after a slightly wild party with colleagues. I caught her in the middle of struggling with our son’s homework… She did not think great the fact that I was having fun, and here I found myself, at 3am, tipsy in a street of Cannes, Côte d’Azur, trying to figure out a very similar maths problem (I remember a bath tub was involved).
I do not have a master’s degree in math. But think this problem has four unknowns. It would require a matrix inversion to solve it. Inverting a 4×4 matrix is tedious. I’ll go by trial and error method like Archimedes did when he developed the calculus basics.
I was a whiz at algebra in high school, 55 years ago, and wrote down the equations but couldn’t recall how to work them. So just started guessing, beginning with eight quarters and 12 dimes; second guess was right—it didn’t take any time at all.
Just had wise-@$$ epiphany; STILL is 20 coins. Problem asked for “how many dimes and quarters does he have”, “not how many dimes and how many quarters”. That would probably be a Sally answer; she just plows through with her own logic!
Using big numbers over-complicates it. The differences in value between a dime and a quarter is 15 cents, so 15*(d-q)=90, d-q=6. Add d+q=20, 2d=26, d=13, q=7.
Argythree over 3 years ago
I was amazed to find a parking meter that took coins the other day. Do kids today even know what dimes and quarters are?
greenbird over 3 years ago
I used to hate word problems like this. But is the answer 13 dimes and 7 quarters?
Templo S.U.D. over 3 years ago
if you studied beforehand, Miss Reichardt, you wouldn’t be asking for help
Jib99928 over 3 years ago
13 dimes, 7 quarters
monkeysky over 3 years ago
So it’s a system of equations:
d+q=20
10d+25q+90=25d+10q
You can substitute every variable d in the second equation with (20-q), to make:
10(20-q)+25q+90=25(20-q)+10q
Which becomes
200-10q+25q+90=500-25q+10q
Which becomes
290+15q=500-15q
Which becomes
30q=210
Finally, you can find that q=7, and substitute that into d+q=20 to find that d=13.
martingcmf over 3 years ago
I can help – 7 quarters and 13 dimes.
ronaldspence over 3 years ago
Patty is too young to be going through “the change” unless it is puberty…
orinoco womble over 3 years ago
Oh those awful story problems! Often listed as “extra credit” on tests. I never did them (I have enough trouble with figures, thanks) and I always suspected she took points off for not doing them.
jimchronister2016 over 3 years ago
What happened to Pigpen, I miss him
in-dubio-pro-rainbow over 3 years ago
PP, I just hope you don’t ask ME for help! Just read the answers above and still too stupid to get it…MATH! EEEWWW! Isn’t there a remedy against it?
cracker65 over 3 years ago
I always hated these torture devices. And I’m good at math.
Tog over 3 years ago
I felt the same way in arithmetic and maths classes Petty.
rickmedley over 3 years ago
13 dimes and 7 quarters
Qiset over 3 years ago
None, after taxes.
ranjith_sankar over 3 years ago
I can relate to Peppermint Patty’s call for help.
dlkrueger33 over 3 years ago
This seems like advanced math (algebra?) for an elementary school student.
jagedlo over 3 years ago
On the Peanuts Wiki site (https://peanuts.fandom.com/wiki/February_1974_comic_strips), if you hover your mouse over the description, it’ll give you the answer to the question…
Darryl Heine over 3 years ago
My answer: $3.50!
zerotvus over 3 years ago
don’t look at me……
SusieB over 3 years ago
I know EXACTLY how you feel PP.
Egrayjames over 3 years ago
My answer to these type of problems is “Let’s go have a beer.”
jrankin1959 over 3 years ago
Yeah, I always said to myself Move on… at that point, too.
bryce.gear over 3 years ago
I’m with you Patti!
dflak over 3 years ago
I am convinced that there is a math gene and some people have it and others don’t.
I have it and I can solve the problem. I just don’t know why I know how to solve the problem.
docachon over 3 years ago
I must have lost my mind. I had As calculus when I was in college. I now can’t solve this problem.
bookworm0812 over 3 years ago
I’m with you, Peppermint Patty. That almost made my head explode.
CraigTalbot over 3 years ago
There is an infinite number of answers that solve this problem. 7 dimes and 1 quarter works. As does 8 dimes and 2 quarters, and 50 dimes and 44 quarters. There just has to be 6 more dimes than quarters.
Major Matt Mason Premium Member over 3 years ago
No soap, radio!
kpw0285 over 3 years ago
20 coins of dimes and quarters MUST add up to more than 90 cents!
johngregor Premium Member over 3 years ago
13 dimes, 7 quarters.
MichalCzerwonko over 3 years ago
The answer is Louis the Millionth
dbhoskisson over 3 years ago
Any number of dimes and quarters where you have 6 fewer quarters than dimes will work:6 d and 0 q = 60 cents, flipped is 1.50. 90 cents more.10d and 4 q = 2 dollars, flipped is 2.90. 90 cents more. 15 d and 9 q = 3.75, flipped is 4.65. 90 cents more. etc. etc.There is not enough info to determine how may dimes and quarters he has.
Ellis97 over 3 years ago
That doesn’t even make sense.
eddie6192 over 3 years ago
A buck three eighty?!!
Watchdog over 3 years ago
Yes, Help!
rugeirn over 3 years ago
The unwillingness many people show to the exercise of rigorous quantitative reasoning is why Las Vegas makes so much money, payday loan sharks are so successful, credit card companies can get away with predatory interest rates, and politicians can pass soak-the-poor tax laws.
Amra Leo over 3 years ago
PUNT!
VICTOR PROULX over 3 years ago
God, I hated school
Otis Rufus Driftwood over 3 years ago
Come again for Big Fudge? Happy Tuesday.
RonnieAThompson Premium Member over 3 years ago
Be safe my friends.
Nougat over 3 years ago
I can relate. Currently, I’m having a really tough math unit, and it’s kinda getting on my nerves. I finally understand it now, but I hope that I can raise my grade a wee bit.
RussellCastine over 3 years ago
He would have 13 dimes and 7 quarters. Thirteen dimes plus seven quarters would equal 3.05 while 13 quarters (3.25) plus 7 dimes would be 3.95 and this concludes the boring math lesson for today.
chris.lemarie over 3 years ago
I once called my wife in NY from a business convention in France. It was 3am there (9pm here), and I thought it was a good moment to catch her after dinner. I was also in high spirits after a slightly wild party with colleagues. I caught her in the middle of struggling with our son’s homework… She did not think great the fact that I was having fun, and here I found myself, at 3am, tipsy in a street of Cannes, Côte d’Azur, trying to figure out a very similar maths problem (I remember a bath tub was involved).
Ken Norris Premium Member over 3 years ago
The whole point of word problems is to teach you to apply math to real life. Now THAT statement should get a bunch of responses.
DCBakerEsq over 3 years ago
Life is just one, neverending word problem. With no Answer Key in the back.
BigEd over 3 years ago
So where in life would a math problem like this be beneficial? If it was important there would probably be a phone app out there for it.
TysonJason over 3 years ago
I swear the teacher is gonna give her a detention if she does not stop screaming
jw35532 over 3 years ago
13 dimes and 7 quarters
Sensei Le Roof over 3 years ago
For the curious, 13 quarters and 7 dimes.
chimpulis over 3 years ago
I do not have a master’s degree in math. But think this problem has four unknowns. It would require a matrix inversion to solve it. Inverting a 4×4 matrix is tedious. I’ll go by trial and error method like Archimedes did when he developed the calculus basics.
MFRXIM Premium Member over 3 years ago
I thought it was a trick question! dimes+ quarters=20.
txmystic over 3 years ago
There are many fine solutions in the comments. Now all Peppermint Patty has to do is get Snoopy to type it up.
I’m sure it will work out fine…
nomomaniacs over 3 years ago
Seven quarters and thirteen dimes
corpcasselbury over 3 years ago
Interesting. I didn’t know they had Common Core math back when this strip first debuted.
ChucklinChuck over 3 years ago
I was a whiz at algebra in high school, 55 years ago, and wrote down the equations but couldn’t recall how to work them. So just started guessing, beginning with eight quarters and 12 dimes; second guess was right—it didn’t take any time at all.
knight1192a over 3 years ago
All I know is he has twenty coins made up of quarters and dimes.
Bluejay Premium Member over 3 years ago
Just had wise-@$$ epiphany; STILL is 20 coins. Problem asked for “how many dimes and quarters does he have”, “not how many dimes and how many quarters”. That would probably be a Sally answer; she just plows through with her own logic!
Bluejay Premium Member over 3 years ago
This was fun! Thanks Everyone for playing nice.
Natarose over 3 years ago
Help is right.
william_bader Premium Member over 3 years ago
Using big numbers over-complicates it. The differences in value between a dime and a quarter is 15 cents, so 15*(d-q)=90, d-q=6. Add d+q=20, 2d=26, d=13, q=7.
Scoutmaster77 over 3 years ago
That’s a riddle, not a math problem. :-)
rstove428 Premium Member over 3 years ago
42
STACEY MARSHALL Premium Member over 3 years ago
Easy: he would still have 20 dimes and quarters, aka coins!
John Jorgensen over 3 years ago
Thirteen dimes and seven quarters, I think. Took me all day to figure that out.
gantech over 3 years ago
The answer is ZERO. I would have paid somebody off to figure it out for me.
AlanTompkins over 3 years ago
I always hated those kind of math queries and still hate such all these years later. Ugh!!