And yet I have tutored college students for years who can’t write a coherent paragraph, let alone a term paper. One woman I know who has her degree in literature writes book reviews on a well known website. If she weren’t clear over in Canada I’d offer to tutor her; she can’t even write a decent sentence without a thousand unnecessary insertions. I wonder who “taught” her to write at the university level, and shudder.
The different types of ‘writing’ require different mindsets.
In essays conciseness is important. Introduction, statement of thesis, explication, summary, conclusion. My initial high school classroom essay assignment required 5 paragraphs of about 5 sentences each, with student choosing from a list of about a dozen topics, and with personal choices acceptable. Some made it look easy. Some aged in place trying to boil the topic down to the basics, and some just could not get there in under a dozen pages.
Scientific themes followed the ‘scientific method.’ Observation, hypothesis, experimentation, evaluation, conclusion.
In fiction writing, on the other hand, the sky was the limit. Choose any theme, any time period, any subject except excess violence and graphic sex. Took 2 weeks to even grade for content and structure. One year lives in memory because a young lady, well known in certain circles asked _What’s the difference between ‘graphic sex’ and ‘regular sex?’ To say there was laughter is to say the sun is a light.
And people say teaching writing is tedious and unnecessary. It probably is the single skill that allows one to express opinions or emotions or to inform about discoveries of all kinds without being shouted down by those who disagree. Else why libraries?
This strip can also be seen as an example of how Watterson was seeing his own strip. He admits in The Calvin and Hobbes Tenth Anniversary Book that there were times when he saw the strip he’d created as a monster. He sometimes rebelled against the rules for comic strips and set new rules which other cartoonists have followed.
Think back to all the years of schooling you had. How much do you really remember? The famous ride of Paul Revere. Everyone knows it.. What was the name of the Horse? You would think that the Horse was just as important to the ride then the man screaming his head off riding him…
This is a real issue. I remember in middle school and high school teachers trying to get the redneck guys in class interested in reading and writing and then giving them “Of Human Bondage” to read and write about. This offered nothing to those guys. Give them a copy of Field and Stream or a book on hunting and ask them to read and write about that, instead. I was the world’s biggest bookworm growing up and even I hated sloughing through “Of Human Bondage” and I refused to finish the “the Grapes of Wrath”! (Thank you, Cliff Notes!) Give people something that interests them and you’ll get an entirely different reaction.
There seems to be a misconception that creative writing is supposed to be fun. Many great writers were tortured by the process. I personally knew a best-selling author of both fiction and non-fiction who killed himself. They say to never go into writing to make money; only write if your stories compel you to write.
School made me think I hated poetry until I realized music was poetry set to music. Example: Read “Richard Corey” then listen to the Simon and Garfunkle version.
If my youngest were in school today, that’s exactly what would happen. He wrote a drew some things that would seriously upset today’s teachers. Luckily, he had teachers with some understanding and a sense of absurd humour. :)
BE THIS GUY over 2 years ago
Stephen King spent most of his time in school in the psychologist’s office.
Charles Barr Premium Member over 2 years ago
That means the school psychologist will soon need a psychologist.
The Calvinosaurus That Calvin Wanted To Discover over 2 years ago
Worth it.
Sugar Bombs 95 over 2 years ago
I feel like this was Bill personally venting about all the writing “rules” he was taught in school.
codycab over 2 years ago
That’s because your definition of “Fun” is really screwed up, Calvin.
Renatus Profuturus Frigeridus Premium Member over 2 years ago
Mrs. W. is a severe teacher only with Calvin, I presume.
sirbadger over 2 years ago
I tried to think of something creative. Imagine Superman swapping outfits with a fashion designer who complains about the awful color scheme.
STEPUP over 2 years ago
Indeed, he’s in the wrong institution. He should be enrolled in a state institution!!!!
Johnny Q Premium Member over 2 years ago
Is this the story where they use the time machine?
Bilan over 2 years ago
Maybe he’s related to Dorothy Parker, who said “I hate writing, but I love having written.”
Susan00100 over 2 years ago
Calvin is right; I’ve always hated writing assignments—even in first grade!!
rshive over 2 years ago
The happy medium is in there somewhere, Calvin.
bluram over 2 years ago
orinoco womble over 2 years ago
And yet I have tutored college students for years who can’t write a coherent paragraph, let alone a term paper. One woman I know who has her degree in literature writes book reviews on a well known website. If she weren’t clear over in Canada I’d offer to tutor her; she can’t even write a decent sentence without a thousand unnecessary insertions. I wonder who “taught” her to write at the university level, and shudder.
rentier over 2 years ago
I always have something other to do during writing!!
sandpiper over 2 years ago
The different types of ‘writing’ require different mindsets.
In essays conciseness is important. Introduction, statement of thesis, explication, summary, conclusion. My initial high school classroom essay assignment required 5 paragraphs of about 5 sentences each, with student choosing from a list of about a dozen topics, and with personal choices acceptable. Some made it look easy. Some aged in place trying to boil the topic down to the basics, and some just could not get there in under a dozen pages.
Scientific themes followed the ‘scientific method.’ Observation, hypothesis, experimentation, evaluation, conclusion.
In fiction writing, on the other hand, the sky was the limit. Choose any theme, any time period, any subject except excess violence and graphic sex. Took 2 weeks to even grade for content and structure. One year lives in memory because a young lady, well known in certain circles asked _What’s the difference between ‘graphic sex’ and ‘regular sex?’ To say there was laughter is to say the sun is a light.
And people say teaching writing is tedious and unnecessary. It probably is the single skill that allows one to express opinions or emotions or to inform about discoveries of all kinds without being shouted down by those who disagree. Else why libraries?
Calvinist1966 over 2 years ago
This is another example of how Calvin often represents the immature side of Watterson’s character and Hobbes represents a more mature side.
Calvinist1966 over 2 years ago
This strip can also be seen as an example of how Watterson was seeing his own strip. He admits in The Calvin and Hobbes Tenth Anniversary Book that there were times when he saw the strip he’d created as a monster. He sometimes rebelled against the rules for comic strips and set new rules which other cartoonists have followed.
jagedlo over 2 years ago
Rolling the eyes, Hobbes? Really?
A Hip loving Canadian... over 2 years ago
The world could use more school psychologists these days.
VegaAlopex over 2 years ago
Calvin reminds me of the two English courses I had to take at Penn State. They were very discouraging.
Tweet&Bleat over 2 years ago
When did they start having school psychologists? I don’t remember them when I was in school.
Wizard of Ahz-no relation over 2 years ago
word processing makes it so much easier. I write the stuff that I like or that comes to me, then back up and connect it all.
uniquename over 2 years ago
These days, they’d probably skip the psychologist and call the police.
mckeonfuneralhomebx over 2 years ago
Think back to all the years of schooling you had. How much do you really remember? The famous ride of Paul Revere. Everyone knows it.. What was the name of the Horse? You would think that the Horse was just as important to the ride then the man screaming his head off riding him…
YippiKiAyMofo over 2 years ago
This is a real issue. I remember in middle school and high school teachers trying to get the redneck guys in class interested in reading and writing and then giving them “Of Human Bondage” to read and write about. This offered nothing to those guys. Give them a copy of Field and Stream or a book on hunting and ask them to read and write about that, instead. I was the world’s biggest bookworm growing up and even I hated sloughing through “Of Human Bondage” and I refused to finish the “the Grapes of Wrath”! (Thank you, Cliff Notes!) Give people something that interests them and you’ll get an entirely different reaction.
txmystic over 2 years ago
My music theory teacher told me it’s better to at least know the rules before you go breaking them…
CrazyLady Premium Member over 2 years ago
I really miss Calvin and Hobbes and wished Bill continued the comic strip : (
wiley207 over 2 years ago
We’ve heard about Calvin often ending up in the school principal’s office, but the school psychologist? That’s a first…
KEA over 2 years ago
actually, it’s probably a good hint about one should viewing writing as a career or not
JMG316 over 2 years ago
LOL!!!!
mistercatworks over 2 years ago
There seems to be a misconception that creative writing is supposed to be fun. Many great writers were tortured by the process. I personally knew a best-selling author of both fiction and non-fiction who killed himself. They say to never go into writing to make money; only write if your stories compel you to write.
Marty241 over 2 years ago
School made me think I hated poetry until I realized music was poetry set to music. Example: Read “Richard Corey” then listen to the Simon and Garfunkle version.
dbradway1 over 2 years ago
Why does this remind me of those kids who commit mass murders after telegraphing their intentions in writing exercises?
Lola85 Premium Member over 2 years ago
I love to write. It’s working with numbers that kills me.
Ariesr over 2 years ago
Why doesn’t he write about Spaceman Spiff?
M2MM over 2 years ago
If my youngest were in school today, that’s exactly what would happen. He wrote a drew some things that would seriously upset today’s teachers. Luckily, he had teachers with some understanding and a sense of absurd humour. :)