Besides a seasonal reference, it also lacks a kiregi or “cutting word”. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kireji Syllable count is the least important characteristic and modern and even classic Japanese hokku may vary from that slightly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haiku
High school English. 1950s. Assignment to read a poem aloud to the class. I chose something from O. Henry – rejected. Suggested a limerick – rejected. Suggested The Cremation of Sam McGee – emphatically rejected. I asked about a selection from Ulysses – teacher (not thinking of James Joyce) agreed. She stopped me on about the third line and I never had to read a poem in class again.
aflhc1984 over 1 year ago
Perfectly boring, sorry Satch!
Randy B Premium Member over 1 year ago
You are technically correct — the best kind of correct.
Jayalexander over 1 year ago
Leaves something to the imagination.
Richard Howland-Bolton Premium Member over 1 year ago
Not really. There’s no seasonal aspect, and I think he’s got too many ‘on’ (not that that’s essential)
Now this is a haiku, AND it’s a limerick (I call them Hairimeraku)
Autumn rain drips, / Walking girl slips. / Yobs cry “Ha!“ / Boo!” and “Ya!” / —-Foolish quips.
iggyman over 1 year ago
Hack up another one Satchel! No, Satchel is good natured, that would be more like Bucky, the “Hair ball King”!
Chithing Premium Member over 1 year ago
I hope this doesn’t start a barrage of haikus. They tend to breed like limericks.
Gandalf over 1 year ago
Nope, not ‘technical perfection’; it’s missing a ‘season word’…
Red State Pinko over 1 year ago
Reminds of Dave Barry’s haiku: A dog is barking / Bark bark bark bark bark bark bark Bark bark bark bark bark
Serial Pedant over 1 year ago
Perfectly boring,Sorry Satch! That just won’t do; Needs more empathy!
Serial Pedant over 1 year ago
Perfectly boring,
Sorry Satch! That just won’t do;
Needs more empathy!
SofaKing Premium Member over 1 year ago
Satchel is technically correct. The best kind of correct.
SavannahJim Premium Member over 1 year ago
Actually, quite moving. In the sense that it moved through ALL of the whole numbers between 0 & 14.
fritzoid Premium Member over 1 year ago
I always thought it was interesting that Twitter posts were limited to 140 characters,* the same as the number of syllables in a sonnet.
*No longer the case, of course.
dpatrickryan Premium Member over 1 year ago
Hai-cool!
mistercatworks over 1 year ago
Traditional Japanese haiku has six rules to its construction. It’s Western sloth that reduced it to a syllable count.
Thomas R. Williams over 1 year ago
Besides a seasonal reference, it also lacks a kiregi or “cutting word”. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kireji Syllable count is the least important characteristic and modern and even classic Japanese hokku may vary from that slightly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haiku
Ebenezer Stooge Premium Member over 1 year ago
Ducks are cute; geese not
Park your car in the garage
Or you’ll be sorry.
Howard'sMyHero over 1 year ago
Ah, so desu ka …!
Betrayral In The Common Room over 1 year ago
Better than Buckys speech about Muppets.
fritzoid Premium Member over 1 year ago
I am shocked, SHOCKED by Satchel’s blatant disregard of formalism.
A haiku without nature imagery is like a limerick that isn’t filthy!
eb110americana over 1 year ago
To be fair, it’s better than most of the horrible, horrible poetry out there. Poetry is the karaoke of writing.
LKrueger41 over 1 year ago
High school English. 1950s. Assignment to read a poem aloud to the class. I chose something from O. Henry – rejected. Suggested a limerick – rejected. Suggested The Cremation of Sam McGee – emphatically rejected. I asked about a selection from Ulysses – teacher (not thinking of James Joyce) agreed. She stopped me on about the third line and I never had to read a poem in class again.
John W Kennedy Premium Member over 1 year ago
English hates haiku. Syllables, like April snow, melt and flow away.
rgcviper over 1 year ago
Satchel the writer
has amazed Rob once again.
How does he do it?