The 3rd-person singular pronoun is the last vestige of gender in the English language, and it would be better off dead. We need a decent gender-neutral “human” pronoun (not “it”, which is for things). Unfortunately, all of the dozen or so that have been proposed thru the years pretty much suck. My own favorite (probably doomed like the rest) was to utilize the 4th and 5th vowels as 1-letters words. “O”, “A”, and “I” are already words, and I like the otherwise unclaimed “U” (2nd-person) and “E” (3rd-person) to round out the complete set.
I’m to old for all this. Wake me up when it is time to make a decision. I would like to see where this ends up. A journey without an end is just dedicated wandering.
Funny, Trudeau is a liberal cartoonist and I get this strip, but in another way it does a good job poking fun at all the labels people have been putting on themselves and others.
With what’s been happening in my family over the years, nothing shocks me any more. For example, when transgendered daughter informed me she’s a lesbian, I told her she’d have to do a lot better than that to bother me.
I think of hermaphrodites and transitioning trans people as “it.” Some people refer to a person of unknown gender as “they” but I think this sounds silly, like the “royal we.” My new friend, who goes by the stage name Eugenia Slimesworth, is a transgender show woman who hasn’t had the operation yet, but plans to someday. You can google pictures of her wacky Cher-like appearance.
The singular “they,” in the absence of any stated preference, is perfectly fine, both socially and grammatically. It actually has a long history to it.
And unlike “it”, it doesn’t carry connotations that the person being referenced isn’t, well, a person.
Hermaphrodites are people who started out as two people, one male, one female. The two fertilized eggs developed into a single embryo. Interestingly, last I checked, a hermaphrodite has one testicle, one ovary.
.
Sometimes this happens with 2 male eggs or two female eggs. A woman in Tallahassee gave birth to children when DNA test of cells collected by a mouth swab indicated he was not their mother but rather their aunt. Fraud was suspected and disproved when she gave birth to another “niece” with witnesses verifying the facts. DNA from other organs showed different origins.
.
There have been people convicted of rape based on confessions and eye-witness testimony but who were later released because DNA from mouth swabs did not match DNA from the rape victim.
.
I wonder if DNA from their semen would have matched. To my knowledge, nobody checked.
BE THIS GUY almost 8 years ago
She’s a GIRL!
onespiceybbw almost 8 years ago
no boobs.
BE THIS GUY almost 8 years ago
Does jerk count as a gender identity?
Flash Gordon almost 8 years ago
She has it backward. X is female, Y is male.
Yes I know it’s a graph but please don’t mix things up, ok?
Night-Gaunt49[Bozo is Boffo] almost 8 years ago
Gender is more cultural than XY chromosomes still the gender and sex of humans isn’t a dichotomy, it is a spectrum just as sexuality is.
Richard S Russell Premium Member almost 8 years ago
The 3rd-person singular pronoun is the last vestige of gender in the English language, and it would be better off dead. We need a decent gender-neutral “human” pronoun (not “it”, which is for things). Unfortunately, all of the dozen or so that have been proposed thru the years pretty much suck. My own favorite (probably doomed like the rest) was to utilize the 4th and 5th vowels as 1-letters words. “O”, “A”, and “I” are already words, and I like the otherwise unclaimed “U” (2nd-person) and “E” (3rd-person) to round out the complete set.
Liverlips McCracken Premium Member almost 8 years ago
Good grief. What a load. Shack up as you wish. It’s none of my business, and I don’t want it to be any of my business.
David Huie Green LoveJoyAndPeace almost 8 years ago
“(0,10)”
rgwalther almost 8 years ago
I am strictly anti-noun.
Ignatz Premium Member almost 8 years ago
It’s standard to address someone as the gender they present themselves to be, and this person pretty clearly is presenting as male.
Adiraiju almost 8 years ago
And then there’s those of us who’re generally addressed in terms like “Get over here, stupid #$&%#$!”
Liam Astle Premium Member almost 8 years ago
Do you really want to be seen dating a straight white male?
Honorable Mention In The Banjo Toss Premium Member almost 8 years ago
Gotta love the blinding jargon in panel four. I used to have to sit through meetings full of words like that.
vaughnrl2003 Premium Member almost 8 years ago
I’m to old for all this. Wake me up when it is time to make a decision. I would like to see where this ends up. A journey without an end is just dedicated wandering.
Kip W almost 8 years ago
So much rushing around. Sometimes you need to stop and scold the clouds.
Kip W almost 8 years ago
If they have a date, it’ll be Sam and Jan at evening.
SeaFox10 almost 8 years ago
So in other words, you’re a moron!
ChrisV almost 8 years ago
Ah, young modern love. (I don’t think Duke is gonna like this!)
hillsmom almost 8 years ago
Hmmm…Jan sort of looks like Rachel Maddow.
Dean almost 8 years ago
Sam’s eyes breaking the 4th wall in panel 5?
AlnicoV almost 8 years ago
Is it throwing fuel on the fire to point out that Jan is actually a gender neutral name as well.
mourdac Premium Member almost 8 years ago
I like the ‘crazy’ versus ‘hot’ axes
Rob Smith Premium Member almost 8 years ago
Shopping is so hard….
BeniHanna6 Premium Member almost 8 years ago
Funny, Trudeau is a liberal cartoonist and I get this strip, but in another way it does a good job poking fun at all the labels people have been putting on themselves and others.
Chuck almost 8 years ago
How about using polar coordinates?
Red Ruffensor almost 8 years ago
With what’s been happening in my family over the years, nothing shocks me any more. For example, when transgendered daughter informed me she’s a lesbian, I told her she’d have to do a lot better than that to bother me.
Godfreydaniel almost 8 years ago
@Night-Gaunt49
Speaking of gelding, don’t you wish Trump’s father would’ve been gelded and thus improved the hell out of the modern world?
jmarkoff2 almost 8 years ago
I think of hermaphrodites and transitioning trans people as “it.” Some people refer to a person of unknown gender as “they” but I think this sounds silly, like the “royal we.” My new friend, who goes by the stage name Eugenia Slimesworth, is a transgender show woman who hasn’t had the operation yet, but plans to someday. You can google pictures of her wacky Cher-like appearance.
braindead Premium Member almost 8 years ago
This MUST be the
Sam and Janet evening
that Sinatra sang about.
frogsandravens almost 8 years ago
The singular “they,” in the absence of any stated preference, is perfectly fine, both socially and grammatically. It actually has a long history to it.
And unlike “it”, it doesn’t carry connotations that the person being referenced isn’t, well, a person.
David Huie Green LoveJoyAndPeace almost 8 years ago
Hermaphrodites are people who started out as two people, one male, one female. The two fertilized eggs developed into a single embryo. Interestingly, last I checked, a hermaphrodite has one testicle, one ovary.
.
Sometimes this happens with 2 male eggs or two female eggs. A woman in Tallahassee gave birth to children when DNA test of cells collected by a mouth swab indicated he was not their mother but rather their aunt. Fraud was suspected and disproved when she gave birth to another “niece” with witnesses verifying the facts. DNA from other organs showed different origins.
.
There have been people convicted of rape based on confessions and eye-witness testimony but who were later released because DNA from mouth swabs did not match DNA from the rape victim.
.
I wonder if DNA from their semen would have matched. To my knowledge, nobody checked.
montessoriteacher almost 8 years ago
God created a woman with 3 boobs. She said what shall I do with the useless boob and god created man!
stepham almost 8 years ago
Sam, as one girl to another, you should definitely not waste any of your time or energy on a boy who can’t even commit to his own sex.
barister almost 8 years ago
This rascal is an airhead….the kind that will become an overpaid, underdeveloped CEO somewhere