I wonder how many readers could not go on with their day without working this out – to answer that little voice of insecurity telling them that they don’t remember anything from their school days. I know I am one of them.
Back in the day when I was in school, we had the same problem except that it was trains and one of them left Pennsylvania Station at 3:45 PM bound for Baltimore. I never understood why until https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XQybKMXL-k
Tracer has a bottle of whiskey, a gun, two bullets and playing cards on the table. He’s concentrating hard while smoking up the room. The baffling case doesn’t stand a chance.
When I pick up medication, my pharmacist assistant asks me if I have any questions. I used the trains leaving Chicago and New York just once. Now they ask me if I have any questions that the pharmacist can answer.
WHAT “satanic force” would even GIVE such a problem to a first grader! There are high school Algebra students that would struggle with that problem. I suffered through algebra! I was one of them!
I think I remember these kind of math problems. But I remember a lot of things that might have happened to me when I was daydreaming in class too. “Rock on” Calvin
This is a variation on a famous humorous anecdote about the math wizard John Von Neuman. His immediate answer gave the impression that he knew the shortcut way of solving it rather than summing the infinite series. He said No; that he indeed summed the series! Google Von Neuman anecdote.
What kind of road? gravel with two lanes.. or one of those interstate where the lanes may be miles apart.. Too many variables to figure this out. Did one go thru the drive thru at McDonald’s…was there a lineup.
My answer to this: in my entire adult life and up through retirement I have NOT ONCE had to calculate a problem like this. I’m sure some folks do… but some folks climb Everest. All through school they taught stuff like this… but not once did they ever teach me how to fill out an income tax form or a myriad other things that would have come in handy throughout life. I really don’t care who the 12th President of the Unites States was and don’t believe I should A) Be required to memorize such nor appreciate that B) Part of my grades were based on such ‘priceless’ information.
The main problem with the education system is it really doesn’t prepare people for everyday life and instead teaches us useless trivia we’ll never need… ever.
That’s my dwagon soapbox for the day. I stickin’ to it unless someone bribes me with pie.
Maybe the math question needs to be personally relevant:
If Hobbes throws a snowball at Susie at 60 Mph, and you throw one at Susie at 30 mph, how far from Susie do you both need to be to hit her simultaneously?
Oh boy, Oh boy, Oh boy. Film Noir! Is the ‘Dame’ that shows up with a ‘mysterious package’ and a ‘story’ to go with it going to be Suzy Derkins??? “Stay Tuned!”
It occurs to me that nowadays, newspapers would get complaints for showing a six-year-old smoking with a whiskey bottle and a revolver nearby. Even if it’s all in his head.
I have never understood why so many people hear “word problem” and have their brain freeze up. Most word problems are actually pretty straight forward. Unlike real world problems which require you to make several guesses before you can even get started…
You can’t be sure about distance, because Jack was stopped for doing 60 in a school zone. You need to figure in the time it takes for a police officer to complete the background check on the vehicle and driver, write the ticket and possibly lecture Joe for being so irresponsible. There may also be other circumstances involved here. For example, Joe may be 92 years old and has a tendency to drive very slowly. Just sayin’. Hiring the detective is the best possible way to solve this dilemma.
BE THIS GUY almost 5 years ago
I hope Calvin is getting help for his drinking.
And the answer is 15 miles.
The Calvinosaurus That Calvin Wanted To Discover almost 5 years ago
I love Tracer Bullet!
codycab almost 5 years ago
Always pulling out the big guns, aren’t they?
retrocool almost 5 years ago
yay,it’s Tracer Bullet ! now I’ve got the theme to ’ Peter Gunn ’ going through my head.
Robin Harwood almost 5 years ago
Why are you asking me? If you know so much about Jack and Joe, why don’t you know how far apart their homes are? I don’t care.
Johnny Q Premium Member almost 5 years ago
The last few weeks RIP HAYWIRE was doing a private eye spoof too.
Watcher almost 5 years ago
Not to far because Joe drove Jack off the road, the end.
Orcatime almost 5 years ago
I always hated word problems in math.
Sonic the Hedgehog. almost 5 years ago
You play detective in a pop quiz. I wish I could do that
sapepgoldman almost 5 years ago
I wonder how many readers could not go on with their day without working this out – to answer that little voice of insecurity telling them that they don’t remember anything from their school days. I know I am one of them.
the_dungeoneer Premium Member almost 5 years ago
If he struggles with 5+4 then this one is gonna be above his pay grade.
SusanSunshine Premium Member almost 5 years ago
Only in Cartoonland do they ask 6-year-olds to solve problems like this when they won’t even learn to multiply or divide for another year or so….
and probably haven’t gotten to “borrowing” in subtraction.
They may figure it out for the sake of the joke…but next week will go back to not being able to solve “what is 26 minus 9?”
dlkrueger33 almost 5 years ago
So glad I’m no longer in school! God, how I HATED those kinds of math problems!
joe607ny Premium Member almost 5 years ago
15 miles, but you’d better check Susie’s answer.
dflak almost 5 years ago
Back in the day when I was in school, we had the same problem except that it was trains and one of them left Pennsylvania Station at 3:45 PM bound for Baltimore. I never understood why until https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XQybKMXL-k
Doug Taylor Premium Member almost 5 years ago
Jack is moving at 60 MPH. Joe is moving at 30 MPH.
What time is it in Bora Bora?
cubswin2016 almost 5 years ago
Calvin is so easily distracted.
vaughnrl2003 Premium Member almost 5 years ago
I have not lead a sheltered life and I swear I have never, ever had to figure out one of those stupid questions in real life.
crobinson019 almost 5 years ago
This is First Grade math?
morningglory73 Premium Member almost 5 years ago
0. The answer is zero because neither Jack nor Joe went anywhere that day. They decided to stay home and watch TV.
YippiKiAyMofo almost 5 years ago
Well, Jack was a Dallas Fan and Joe loved the Packers…so pretty far, really.
Who, me? almost 5 years ago
Tracer has a bottle of whiskey, a gun, two bullets and playing cards on the table. He’s concentrating hard while smoking up the room. The baffling case doesn’t stand a chance.
jpayne4040 almost 5 years ago
Hey, as long as it gets Calvin to the right answer…
SweetSinger almost 5 years ago
Wow, accelerated learning. Algebra in first grade.
SweetSinger almost 5 years ago
Or as Douglas Adams would have it: 42
fred_dot_u Premium Member almost 5 years ago
When I pick up medication, my pharmacist assistant asks me if I have any questions. I used the trains leaving Chicago and New York just once. Now they ask me if I have any questions that the pharmacist can answer.
AtheisticallyYours1 almost 5 years ago
WHAT “satanic force” would even GIVE such a problem to a first grader! There are high school Algebra students that would struggle with that problem. I suffered through algebra! I was one of them!
hoffquotes2 almost 5 years ago
Seems a little advanced for elementary school
kerry cargile Premium Member almost 5 years ago
I think I remember these kind of math problems. But I remember a lot of things that might have happened to me when I was daydreaming in class too. “Rock on” Calvin
mikeszeller Premium Member almost 5 years ago
Please show your work.
mikeszeller Premium Member almost 5 years ago
Closing speed is 60+90 = 90mph10 minutes @ 90 mph = 10/60 * 90 = 15 miles
BiathlonNut almost 5 years ago
I sucked at arithmetic, did OK at algebra, did well at calculus, and was outstanding at differential equations. My usual nonconforming pattern.
sonnygreen almost 5 years ago
60 mph is 1 mi per minute + 30 mph = .5 mi per minute is 1.5 mi per minute X 10 minutes = 15 miles
fshuler almost 5 years ago
Algebra in what, first grade?
WCraft Premium Member almost 5 years ago
“The dame seeking answers was big and had white hair and glasses – just like every other grandmother in this dark and grimy city…”
codedaddy almost 5 years ago
This is a variation on a famous humorous anecdote about the math wizard John Von Neuman. His immediate answer gave the impression that he knew the shortcut way of solving it rather than summing the infinite series. He said No; that he indeed summed the series! Google Von Neuman anecdote.
Alberta Oil Premium Member almost 5 years ago
What kind of road? gravel with two lanes.. or one of those interstate where the lanes may be miles apart.. Too many variables to figure this out. Did one go thru the drive thru at McDonald’s…was there a lineup.
Snoots almost 5 years ago
My answer to this: in my entire adult life and up through retirement I have NOT ONCE had to calculate a problem like this. I’m sure some folks do… but some folks climb Everest. All through school they taught stuff like this… but not once did they ever teach me how to fill out an income tax form or a myriad other things that would have come in handy throughout life. I really don’t care who the 12th President of the Unites States was and don’t believe I should A) Be required to memorize such nor appreciate that B) Part of my grades were based on such ‘priceless’ information.
The main problem with the education system is it really doesn’t prepare people for everyday life and instead teaches us useless trivia we’ll never need… ever.
That’s my dwagon soapbox for the day. I stickin’ to it unless someone bribes me with pie.
squiggle almost 5 years ago
the kid is gonna be a rocket scientist
Grimmwood900 almost 5 years ago
Wow one day he’s being asked to add 3+2, the next day he’s getting an Algebra word problem you might see on the SAT. No wonder he hates school.
Mediatech almost 5 years ago
The most baffling part of the question is why is the United States the only major country that still does not use the metric System?
d_mock almost 5 years ago
14.925
Andrew Sleeth almost 5 years ago
He’ll need more than a PI if they tell him to factor in acceleration.
Lightpainter almost 5 years ago
Maybe the math question needs to be personally relevant:
If Hobbes throws a snowball at Susie at 60 Mph, and you throw one at Susie at 30 mph, how far from Susie do you both need to be to hit her simultaneously?
Ka`ōnōhi`ula`okahōkūmiomio`ehiku Premium Member almost 5 years ago
So glad someone else solved this. I’m not quite awake enough yet.
Ryan Plut almost 5 years ago
Oh boy, Oh boy, Oh boy. Film Noir! Is the ‘Dame’ that shows up with a ‘mysterious package’ and a ‘story’ to go with it going to be Suzy Derkins??? “Stay Tuned!”
Stephen Gilberg almost 5 years ago
It occurs to me that nowadays, newspapers would get complaints for showing a six-year-old smoking with a whiskey bottle and a revolver nearby. Even if it’s all in his head.
kevin87031 almost 5 years ago
Why are so many people eager to point out that they hate the study of how numbers behave?
Concretionist almost 5 years ago
I have never understood why so many people hear “word problem” and have their brain freeze up. Most word problems are actually pretty straight forward. Unlike real world problems which require you to make several guesses before you can even get started…
Dr. Quatermass almost 5 years ago
I think you can file this under Common Bore… ZZZZZZZZZ
Doctor Go almost 5 years ago
They both made the Kessel run in less than twelve parsecs.
weatherford.joe Premium Member almost 5 years ago
This problem seems a bit too complex for first graders.
James Aiello Premium Member almost 5 years ago
You can’t be sure about distance, because Jack was stopped for doing 60 in a school zone. You need to figure in the time it takes for a police officer to complete the background check on the vehicle and driver, write the ticket and possibly lecture Joe for being so irresponsible. There may also be other circumstances involved here. For example, Joe may be 92 years old and has a tendency to drive very slowly. Just sayin’. Hiring the detective is the best possible way to solve this dilemma.