My answer would probably have been the same as Caulfield’s when I was Caulfield’s age. Most of the things I give thanks for now are stuff that I worked to obtain or maintain. (Relationships it is maintain, pretty much everything else it is obtain.)
So there’s no point in wishing for things, since whatever nice things happen to you would have happened anyway, whether you wished for them or not. Remember that this Christmas, when the supply chain goes all Grinch on you.
The old adage, “Be careful what you wish for, you may get your wish,” comes to mind, but so does the joke, “How do you make God laugh: Tell Him your life plans.” You can’t always be thankful for the disasters you avoid, because you may not know what they were, or they may only be disasters from your current point in life.
Hind sight is 20/20, but only if you’re walking backwards (I dismissed having eyes in the back of your head.)
So if half the things you like are wishes that came true and the other half are things that just happened, it means that working hard to get things you want is a waste of time.
C about 3 years ago
#denial
Concretionist about 3 years ago
I’ve seen this trope quite a few times from Mallett. Not that it’s any less clever for being clever WITHIN the pattern.
35&45 about 3 years ago
dreams and wishes can come true___
Elvis Aaron Presley
Doug K about 3 years ago
50% could actually be quite statistically significant – depending on one’s expectations.
Sanspareil about 3 years ago
There’s no probability that he is probably wrong and equally no probability he is probably right!
hyddyr about 3 years ago
I like half and half in my coffee.
e.groves about 3 years ago
The kids seem to get more learning from Frazz than their teacher.
sandpiper about 3 years ago
Caulfield is working from memory. Accuracy is never assured.
pony21 Premium Member about 3 years ago
Regarding Frazz’s question – my answer would be about the same as Caulfield’s.
MS72 about 3 years ago
Some people use half & half in their coffee.
DM2860 about 3 years ago
My answer would probably have been the same as Caulfield’s when I was Caulfield’s age. Most of the things I give thanks for now are stuff that I worked to obtain or maintain. (Relationships it is maintain, pretty much everything else it is obtain.)
seismic-2 Premium Member about 3 years ago
So there’s no point in wishing for things, since whatever nice things happen to you would have happened anyway, whether you wished for them or not. Remember that this Christmas, when the supply chain goes all Grinch on you.
poppacapsmokeblower about 3 years ago
The old adage, “Be careful what you wish for, you may get your wish,” comes to mind, but so does the joke, “How do you make God laugh: Tell Him your life plans.” You can’t always be thankful for the disasters you avoid, because you may not know what they were, or they may only be disasters from your current point in life.
Hind sight is 20/20, but only if you’re walking backwards (I dismissed having eyes in the back of your head.)
Richard S Russell Premium Member about 3 years ago
My doc recommends skim milk on my cereal, but I still prefer half and half myself.
Bilan about 3 years ago
So if half the things you like are wishes that came true and the other half are things that just happened, it means that working hard to get things you want is a waste of time.