I write devotionals on a Christian page on Facebook, Be the Light. Before I post them, my younger daughter reads them. She calls herself my copy editor.
I get the joke, but I’m also reminded of a post I saw (on tumblr, I think) from someone who does critiques for a living. The big thing isn’t just saying “Loved this, hated this part, LOATHED this, ADORED that” because everyone’s taste is different, it’s asking good and useful questions, especially if you found something unclear.
I promise to tell the truth, the whole truth (up to the point where you won’t feel offended) and nothing but the truth (up to the point where the truth may hurt you … and you hurt me).
Find some small typos and correct them to show that you read it and than do read it and give that honest aswer. Beans and franks everyday won’t be all that bad…….
I once beta read a novel my cousin had written. She made it very clear she wanted constructive criticism and that saying “Everything’s great” would be a colossal waste of time.
allen@home 11 months ago
Darryl if you know what’s good for you. Give Wanda a glowing review.
calvin123 11 months ago
Hahaha so true:D
cracker65 11 months ago
Tell her to ask you if she looks fat. It will be a lot less painful.
HappyDog/ᵀʳʸ ᴮᵒᶻᵒ ⁴ ᵗʰᵉ ᶠᵘⁿ ᵒᶠ ᶦᵗ Premium Member 11 months ago
Read your whole book? Can I at least sit down, and do you need your computer for the next hour or two?
danketaz Premium Member 11 months ago
Who knows? Maybe he’ll like a kale-based diet.
iggyman 11 months ago
Criticism not allowed Darryl!
hariseldon59 11 months ago
Maybe he should hire a food taster.
cdward 11 months ago
Just not fair. Never ask for an opinion about your writing from someone who has something to lose by telling you the truth.
m b 11 months ago
Happy New Year To All
BenGMan 11 months ago
Exciting!
eced52 11 months ago
Oh, it’s marvelous dear, I can’t wait to read it in paperback.
tremaine53 11 months ago
“Ohhhhh! You want my DIShonest opinion!”
SquidGamerGal 11 months ago
Ugh… That what they always say when the know their story suck out loud!
Just-me 11 months ago
Careful there Darryl, choose the words in your review wisely.
ladykat 11 months ago
Happy New Year!
cdillon85 11 months ago
Got to love emotional blackmail.
Wren Fahel 11 months ago
I write devotionals on a Christian page on Facebook, Be the Light. Before I post them, my younger daughter reads them. She calls herself my copy editor.
MS72 11 months ago
“Oops, I ACCIDENTALLY deleted it.”
ChessPirate 11 months ago
“Honest is as honest is allowed”…
One of my favorite bits from “The Big Bang Theory”:
Bernadette: Well, is there anything about me you’re keeping inside?
Howard: I’m not answering that. It’s a trap.
Bernadette: So there are things you don’t like.
Howard: And here I am in the trap. You just keep talking, I’m gonna chew my leg off.
Bernadette: Just tell me one thing that bothers you, and I promise I won’t get mad.
Howard: Okay. The truth is, sometimes, you’re just too beautiful.
(Howard shakes his head angrily for one second)
Bernadette: (she is now very cross) Oh, Howie, be serious.
Howard: Okay, okay. I really don’t like how your wings poke me when we sleep ’cause you’re an angel.
Bernadette: Okay, fine, maybe it was a bad idea.
KageKat 11 months ago
I get the joke, but I’m also reminded of a post I saw (on tumblr, I think) from someone who does critiques for a living. The big thing isn’t just saying “Loved this, hated this part, LOATHED this, ADORED that” because everyone’s taste is different, it’s asking good and useful questions, especially if you found something unclear.
Daltongang Premium Member 11 months ago
Wow, they must have reached that no sex stage in their marriage already, if Wanda is threatening Darryl with food.
nosirrom 11 months ago
What is the book about? Lucrezia Borgia?
prrdh 11 months ago
That’s honest as in “honest”.
CrimsonOne18 11 months ago
HAPPY NEW YEAR to all of you! I enjoy reading your comments every morning, even when I disagree. Have a wonderful 2024!
wordsmeet 11 months ago
Ah, the neverending baby blues have become the neverending Wanda blues!
Doug K 11 months ago
I promise to tell the truth, the whole truth (up to the point where you won’t feel offended) and nothing but the truth (up to the point where the truth may hurt you … and you hurt me).
Sherlock5 11 months ago
Never ask for an honest opinion if you don’t want an honest opinion,
Frank Burns Eats Worms 11 months ago
Tell her the truth, as your stomach sees it.
J-Yoshi64 11 months ago
If you don’t actually want his honest opinion, just say so. He mature and admit to your insecurity.
Zen-of-Zinfandel 11 months ago
But Darryl lifts the heavy salt pellet bags for soft water.
christelisbetty 11 months ago
It was a dark and stormy request…..
kab2rb 11 months ago
Wanda you asked too much.GC is color, yet Arcamax is not.Happy 2024 New Year.
rshive 11 months ago
Knew that there had to be a hitch.
raybarb44 11 months ago
Find some small typos and correct them to show that you read it and than do read it and give that honest aswer. Beans and franks everyday won’t be all that bad…….
Gabby 11 months ago
Then it’s not an honest opinion. You shouldn’t put conditions on it, Wanda, if you really want his honest opinion.
brick10 11 months ago
I love it (you) and I’m sure it will be a best seller.
The Quiet One 11 months ago
Honest opinion, providing it’s a glowing review.
John Jorgensen 11 months ago
I once beta read a novel my cousin had written. She made it very clear she wanted constructive criticism and that saying “Everything’s great” would be a colossal waste of time.
ToneeRhianRose about 2 months ago
Haha! (^▽^)
Sherlock5 about 2 months ago
You do an author no favor by telling her the writing is great when it’s not.