It depends on how we define ‘sound’. If we define it as ‘vibrating air’, then I agree, a falling tree makes a sound. BUT, if we define it as a conscious experience, the lonesome falling tree does not make a sound. There, problem solved.
The summer I spent in the northern Ontario bush, we discovered that birch trees rotted while standing. We enjoyed playing Hulk and pushing over large trees.
Wanda, every time Zoe tries to rat out Hammie, smile and say “Hammie doing those things just makes me love him all the more! So, thanks, Zoe for telling me! I’ll go get Hammie an ice cream later today.”
The actual philosophical question is whether it makes a noise. Sound is an objective phenomenon, independent of observers. Noise is a subjective judgment, requiring an observer able to make the judgment that it’s noise.
only human arrogance would assume that a person would need to hear it…what about all the birds and other wildlife within earshot? I guess they don’t count? Lol!
They seemed to have abandoned the spitwad incident. I’m surprised that no one has considered separating Hammie and Trent. If not separate classrooms, separate sides of the room. Trent’s been a bad influence since preschool. The only time I have seen him WITHOUT a malicious expression was when he was angelically denying any involvement with the spitwads.
In physics, sound is a vibration that propagates as an acoustic wave through a transmission medium such as a gas, liquid or solid. In human physiology and psychology, sound is the reception of such waves and their perception by the brain. WikipediaThe accepted frequencies are 20-20,000Hz.
danketaz Premium Member 11 months ago
If you weren’t around to see it, did it really happen?
Cornelius Noodleman 11 months ago
Does it make a sound? Who cares.
nickdnd 11 months ago
If tattling was an art form, this girl would be a celebrated master.
iggyman 11 months ago
Your stretching the truth again Zoe, hope your Mother sees through you!
BenGMan 11 months ago
She’s gonna ignore it, because most trees are big.
GerryRoss 11 months ago
And once again, Zoe gets an A+ for her Tattling 101 class.
JoeStoppinghem Premium Member 11 months ago
Yes, it makes a sound. The air molecules are vibrated when it crashes. Sound does not require to be heard.
Piper_13 Premium Member 11 months ago
It depends on how we define ‘sound’. If we define it as ‘vibrating air’, then I agree, a falling tree makes a sound. BUT, if we define it as a conscious experience, the lonesome falling tree does not make a sound. There, problem solved.
cracker65 11 months ago
Zoe, shut up. Jeez.
Geophyzz 11 months ago
The summer I spent in the northern Ontario bush, we discovered that birch trees rotted while standing. We enjoyed playing Hulk and pushing over large trees.
tremaine53 11 months ago
Profiles In Bad Sisterhood, brought to you by Chef Boy-ar-di, where we take better care of your car.
tremaine53 11 months ago
Wanda, every time Zoe tries to rat out Hammie, smile and say “Hammie doing those things just makes me love him all the more! So, thanks, Zoe for telling me! I’ll go get Hammie an ice cream later today.”
Just-me 11 months ago
Hammie doing sit-ups?
DaBump Premium Member 11 months ago
No, he’s pushing philos over. He’s becoming a philosoverer.
ladykat 11 months ago
Yes, it does.
KageKat 11 months ago
I’m surprised Zoe never heard of that little thought exercise before.
pheets 11 months ago
Kids like Zoe never lasted long in private school :D
gluetrap 11 months ago
If a tree falls on a mime in the forest does anybody care?
6foot6 11 months ago
IS that the reason the bear went over the mountain? to see what made that sound?
DawnQuinn1 11 months ago
The earth needs all the trees it can get.
Daltongang Premium Member 11 months ago
Well Zoe is working on her woman listening to a man skills again.
ChessPirate 11 months ago
Q: If Hammie does something wrong and Zoe is not around to see it, does she still tattle?
A: Yes.
Zen-of-Zinfandel 11 months ago
Zoe is stumped.
zionwolfe09 11 months ago
That’s deep Hammie…
LaughterIsJoyMuliplied 11 months ago
Didn’t see that one coming.
charlp Premium Member 11 months ago
The actual philosophical question is whether it makes a noise. Sound is an objective phenomenon, independent of observers. Noise is a subjective judgment, requiring an observer able to make the judgment that it’s noise.
cc99562 11 months ago
Very important question that my science class still won’t answer for me.
wildlandwaters 11 months ago
only human arrogance would assume that a person would need to hear it…what about all the birds and other wildlife within earshot? I guess they don’t count? Lol!
DKHenderson 11 months ago
They seemed to have abandoned the spitwad incident. I’m surprised that no one has considered separating Hammie and Trent. If not separate classrooms, separate sides of the room. Trent’s been a bad influence since preschool. The only time I have seen him WITHOUT a malicious expression was when he was angelically denying any involvement with the spitwads.
David Huie Green LoveJoyAndPeace 11 months ago
If a man is a thousand miles away from the nearest woman and he says something, is he still wrong?
Answer: Well of course he is.
raybarb44 11 months ago
That’s a rather philosophical thought from Hammy at his age……
The Quiet One 11 months ago
Oh Zoe, when will you grow up.
rasputin's horoscope 11 months ago
UlrigJaeger Premium Member 11 months ago
Vibration that propagates as an acoustic wave
In physics, sound is a vibration that propagates as an acoustic wave through a transmission medium such as a gas, liquid or solid. In human physiology and psychology, sound is the reception of such waves and their perception by the brain. WikipediaThe accepted frequencies are 20-20,000Hz.
Curiosity Premium Member 11 months ago
Dumb question and very anthropocentric. The sound is made, and at the very least the bear heard it.
ToneeRhianRose 3 months ago
Haha! (^▽^)