Moms have never understood the joy that comes playing with a child’s mind. It’s a mystery how such a natural form of parental communication could escape them.
What always gets me to worrying, okay I have always weighed the truck I drive at the scales and it comes just under 10 tons. 9 and a half tons to be precise. No problem right? But what worries me is what would happen if I am just about half way across the bridge and another truck also weighing just under 10 tons starts to cross from the other direction and we meet at the middle?
In the third panel I think he means weigh the second to last truck. It would be hard to weigh the last truck since it would be broken into a thousand pieces at the bottom of the gorge. How can they be sure they collected every single piece to find the total weight? Of course if the engineers in that country were smarter they’d weigh the last truck BEFORE it crossed the bridge, not after.
I have been reading the comments you made about my reference on Sunday to our recent conversations. I am afraid that our conversations don’t seem to be as good-natured as they originally were. You once said that you thought I was “nearly as imaginative as Calvin”. I think that you meant that as a compliment and I took it as one.
You say that I keep bringing up the same arguments. I suppose that is true as I keep stating that I originally assumed Hobbes was part of Calvin’s imagination but changed my mind. I have sometimes mentioned the different reasons why I stopped believing Hobbes to be part of Calvin’s wonderful imagination including comments by Bill Watterson himself.
About 20 years ago in the wilds of South Jersey, some guy decided to drive a crane (maybe 70 tons) over a small bridge (limit maybe 10 tons). He made it the first time. Coming back was a different story.
In a world full of fake news, where misinformation is a weapon wielded efficiently by foreign forces, it’s important to double check all your information.
Not to get too serious, but I actually think this is an important part of the learning process. Many’s the time I gave my boys ridiculous, convoluted answers which both delighted them for the absurdity and prodded them into thinking what the real answer might be.
My kid took part in a contest to build the strongest bridge out of popsicle sticks. They chose the winner using a machine that put more and more weight on it until it broke.
My son who eventually wound up as a civil engineer, entered a contest with this team to build a bridge with matchsticks and glue. The team that built the strongest bridge won.
After all the competition was eliminated and they had used every weight in the lab, they had to go to the gym and borrow some bar bell weights. When the bridge finally did break, pieces went flying everywhere.
There was a lot of pent-up energy in that structure.
That’s how they used to build TVs. They would design the most perfect TV from an engineering standpoint. Then they would take out parts until it quit working. Then they would put the last part back in and sell the set.
Read a book about the building of the Brooklyn bridge. Started after the Civil War and finished during the1870’s. It was a time of a great deal of corruption in politics and building trades. A lot different from now, Right? Any way about 1948 there was a lot of concern about the old bridge failing and local government decided to have some engineers check it. Engineering team went over it carefully and rendered the verdict that it really needed a new coat of paint.
I had a friend whose husband built bridges. She said as they drove around the country, the conditions of most bridges they saw scared them as being very worn and dangerous- and this was about 10 years ago.
Fortunately, you only have to run the destructive testing once, then you do the math to apply it to the general class of bridges of the same type. See, that’s why mathematics is important. Saves a lot on trucks.
Look Dear explaining to kid his age about calculating structural loading based on materials, the terrain and why the arch is there would not be as entertaining as my story.
So, they weigh the truck that collapsed the bridge? How can they be sure they retrieved all the parts of the truck? They miss a couple of weights and discover that the load limit is 500 lb. less than the last truck that successfully crossed?
In PA they have been working on infrastructure with bridges for about 10 years now, they have found out that a lot of the old bridges around here, which most are very old, aren’t able to hold the load of trucks going over them anymore and that they have caused deterioration and instability in the bridges. They have been building new bridges all over the state and in our county they have a couple left to redo then all the bridges will be new and able to hold the heavier loads.
One big problem with bridges for politicians is if you build a new bridge, hurray!, you get to have a big celebration perhaps even name it after yourself and the users will credit you for the bridge. OTOH, repair a bridge and nobody even notices the bridge not collapsing.
In NY our former governor named a major replacement bridge for his father with whom he shares a last name. AHEM! He still had to resign.
Of course, they learned to build scale models of bridges and have hamsters drive over them until they collapsed. Today, we use simulations with influencers driving the trucks. :)
BE THIS GUY about 3 years ago
First thing Dad learned in law school is never admit you don’t know something.
dadthedawg Premium Member about 3 years ago
It’s called infrastructure…..
Renatus Profuturus Frigeridus Premium Member about 3 years ago
And all the drivers are would-be suicides.
codycab about 3 years ago
“And no, they don’t use crash test dummies.”
sirbadger about 3 years ago
I’m sure that was done at one point in time and then engineers developed equations to calculate that.
in.amongst about 3 years ago
Dad and son unleashed and mom reaching the end of her tether – lovely! Just a normal family.
C about 3 years ago
Those engineers have all the fun
alaskajohn1 about 3 years ago
Even if your client is guilty defend him anyway; then take the money and run. It’s called the Guiliani approach.
Papared25 about 3 years ago
Moms have never understood the joy that comes playing with a child’s mind. It’s a mystery how such a natural form of parental communication could escape them.
Concretionist about 3 years ago
And the best part: More employment for bridge builders!
hariseldon59 about 3 years ago
I love it when Dad messes with Calvin’s mind like that
Macushlalondra about 3 years ago
And ruin his fun? With a kid like Calvin, Dad needs all the fun he can get. I love it when he plays mind games with Calvin.
rklynch about 3 years ago
But mom. Where’s the fun in that???
LeftCoastKen Premium Member about 3 years ago
Why do you think Dad doesn’t know the right answer, Mom? Are you sure that wasn’t it?
Johnny Q Premium Member about 3 years ago
Calvin: “Dad, how does a carburetor work?”
Dad: “I can’t tell you.”
“Why not?”
“It’s a secret!”
“No, it isn’t—you just don’t know!”
JudasPeckerwood about 3 years ago
Sounds legit. Remind not to apply for any bridge tester jobs.
Imagine about 3 years ago
Actually, he is not far off. In Russia they actually did that on occasion.
Sokka the Great about 3 years ago
Honestly that sounds like a reasonable answer
dcdete. about 3 years ago
What always gets me to worrying, okay I have always weighed the truck I drive at the scales and it comes just under 10 tons. 9 and a half tons to be precise. No problem right? But what worries me is what would happen if I am just about half way across the bridge and another truck also weighing just under 10 tons starts to cross from the other direction and we meet at the middle?
dcdete. about 3 years ago
In the third panel I think he means weigh the second to last truck. It would be hard to weigh the last truck since it would be broken into a thousand pieces at the bottom of the gorge. How can they be sure they collected every single piece to find the total weight? Of course if the engineers in that country were smarter they’d weigh the last truck BEFORE it crossed the bridge, not after.
Count Olaf Premium Member about 3 years ago
I thought that was the answer.
Calvinist1966 about 3 years ago
Another marvellous example of Dad’s imagination at work. As Calvin says, he should have guessed it himself. Dad and Calvin do think alike at times.
einarbt about 3 years ago
It really is no wonder that Calvin is the way he is given his gene pool.
Calvinist1966 about 3 years ago
Dear Brian,
I have been reading the comments you made about my reference on Sunday to our recent conversations. I am afraid that our conversations don’t seem to be as good-natured as they originally were. You once said that you thought I was “nearly as imaginative as Calvin”. I think that you meant that as a compliment and I took it as one.
You say that I keep bringing up the same arguments. I suppose that is true as I keep stating that I originally assumed Hobbes was part of Calvin’s imagination but changed my mind. I have sometimes mentioned the different reasons why I stopped believing Hobbes to be part of Calvin’s wonderful imagination including comments by Bill Watterson himself.
deepstblu about 3 years ago
About 20 years ago in the wilds of South Jersey, some guy decided to drive a crane (maybe 70 tons) over a small bridge (limit maybe 10 tons). He made it the first time. Coming back was a different story.
SNVBD about 3 years ago
This is the type of nonsense I tell my children.
In a world full of fake news, where misinformation is a weapon wielded efficiently by foreign forces, it’s important to double check all your information.
azrael2000 about 3 years ago
I wondered how Calvin had his brain broken… but you have to give Dad an “A” for originality, and an “A” for out of the box thinking!
Who, me? about 3 years ago
Judging by mom’s cross expression in the last panel, I’m surprised she called him dear.
cdward about 3 years ago
Not to get too serious, but I actually think this is an important part of the learning process. Many’s the time I gave my boys ridiculous, convoluted answers which both delighted them for the absurdity and prodded them into thinking what the real answer might be.
pkford about 3 years ago
It is called the bridge formula
Skeptical Meg about 3 years ago
My kid took part in a contest to build the strongest bridge out of popsicle sticks. They chose the winner using a machine that put more and more weight on it until it broke.
So, reasonable.
tremaine53 about 3 years ago
I don’t understand why mom is so MAD! Look at that face! (Or more specifically, look at that MOUTH!)
Nuke Road Warrior about 3 years ago
It’s complicated, and involves math.
nsr60 about 3 years ago
Truck driver with a 12-ton rig: “Hey, I don’t see any cops around, I’m going for it.”
jagedlo about 3 years ago
Reminds me of the Jeff Foxworthy bit about how long they make the rope for the bungee jump…
dflak about 3 years ago
My son who eventually wound up as a civil engineer, entered a contest with this team to build a bridge with matchsticks and glue. The team that built the strongest bridge won.
After all the competition was eliminated and they had used every weight in the lab, they had to go to the gym and borrow some bar bell weights. When the bridge finally did break, pieces went flying everywhere.
There was a lot of pent-up energy in that structure.
colddonkey about 3 years ago
Oh like mom majored in Architecture? Does she have a better answer?
Susan00100 about 3 years ago
Dad is already VERY low in Calvin’s esteem. Why add ignorance?
vaughnrl2003 Premium Member about 3 years ago
The trouble with Dad level BS is that it’s hard to smell a warning over the aftershave.
Chris about 3 years ago
but I like his answer better.
proclusstudent about 3 years ago
Probably the first bridge designs were made that way.
bbenoit about 3 years ago
If you ask a man to mansplain you get what you asked for.
Tallguy about 3 years ago
Just about my favorite Calvin and Hobbes ever. My other favorite is when Dad tells him they keep the sun in Sedona at night.
uniquename about 3 years ago
The real answer is worse Calvin. It’s called “math”.
nathan.sheriff3 about 3 years ago
The Dads answer would have been my answer too! Sometimes the truth needs a little creative spark.
BiggerNate91 about 3 years ago
Lighten up, mom
garysmigs about 3 years ago
trial and error!
tme tested!
A Hip loving Canadian... about 3 years ago
Dad has done it again. Good one too.
wiley207 about 3 years ago
I like how their car is only bouncing slightly in the first panel, compared to other strips where the car can bounce fairly high when driving.
swanridge about 3 years ago
The best part of being a grandparent is telling kids wildly wrong stuff! It’s sort of like our own private Fox news.
Steverino Premium Member about 3 years ago
That’s how they used to build TVs. They would design the most perfect TV from an engineering standpoint. Then they would take out parts until it quit working. Then they would put the last part back in and sell the set.
oldlady07 Premium Member about 3 years ago
Read a book about the building of the Brooklyn bridge. Started after the Civil War and finished during the1870’s. It was a time of a great deal of corruption in politics and building trades. A lot different from now, Right? Any way about 1948 there was a lot of concern about the old bridge failing and local government decided to have some engineers check it. Engineering team went over it carefully and rendered the verdict that it really needed a new coat of paint.
smsrt about 3 years ago
I find that refreshingly logical… in a Calvinistic sort of way.
Alexander the Good Enough about 3 years ago
My theory is that Dad knows better, as dads often do, but is just having a lot of fun pulling Calvin’s leg. Calvin enjoys it. Mom, however…
BTW, oftentimes a good and very acceptable answer for kid-questions like that is “Magic!”
WCraft Premium Member about 3 years ago
Actually, I like that answer. It does make sense. I’m waiting for the father to explain to Calvin how they test load limits on elevators…
mindjob about 3 years ago
And chocolate milk comes from brown cows
Dr. Quatermass about 3 years ago
If the bickering isn’t gonna stop, that’s (sadly) how the infrastructure bill will end.
hornacek about 3 years ago
This is an all time classic. I think of this strip whenever I see a LOAD LIMIT sign.
kartis about 3 years ago
Humour is our only legal revenge on our children.
Lightpainter about 3 years ago
I had a friend whose husband built bridges. She said as they drove around the country, the conditions of most bridges they saw scared them as being very worn and dangerous- and this was about 10 years ago.
schaefer jim about 3 years ago
Dad right you know!
Chlokara about 3 years ago
How else would they do it?
onespiceybbw about 3 years ago
I don’t know, sounds reasonable to me . . . .
mistercatworks about 3 years ago
Fortunately, you only have to run the destructive testing once, then you do the math to apply it to the general class of bridges of the same type. See, that’s why mathematics is important. Saves a lot on trucks.
shamest Premium Member about 3 years ago
Look Dear explaining to kid his age about calculating structural loading based on materials, the terrain and why the arch is there would not be as entertaining as my story.
akb02 about 3 years ago
No wonder your son’s always believing such nonsense!
sousamannd about 3 years ago
but it is funny – and that is what a comic is supposed to do – make us laugh! Calvin always does!
Jon Premium Member about 3 years ago
So, they weigh the truck that collapsed the bridge? How can they be sure they retrieved all the parts of the truck? They miss a couple of weights and discover that the load limit is 500 lb. less than the last truck that successfully crossed?
Otis Rufus Driftwood about 3 years ago
Life before Google.
Sambora1 about 3 years ago
In PA they have been working on infrastructure with bridges for about 10 years now, they have found out that a lot of the old bridges around here, which most are very old, aren’t able to hold the load of trucks going over them anymore and that they have caused deterioration and instability in the bridges. They have been building new bridges all over the state and in our county they have a couple left to redo then all the bridges will be new and able to hold the heavier loads.
lindz.coop Premium Member about 3 years ago
Not sure he’s that far off the mark…
proclusstudent about 3 years ago
One big problem with bridges for politicians is if you build a new bridge, hurray!, you get to have a big celebration perhaps even name it after yourself and the users will credit you for the bridge. OTOH, repair a bridge and nobody even notices the bridge not collapsing.
In NY our former governor named a major replacement bridge for his father with whom he shares a last name. AHEM! He still had to resign.
mistercatworks over 1 year ago
Of course, they learned to build scale models of bridges and have hamsters drive over them until they collapsed. Today, we use simulations with influencers driving the trucks. :)