From the great Tom Lehrer… I am never forget the day I first meet the great Lobachevsky In one word he told me secret of success in mathematics Plagiarize Plagiarize Let no one else’s work evade your eyes Remember why the good Lord made your eyes So don’t shade your eyes But plagiarize, plagiarize, plagiarize Only be sure always to call it please “Research”
Milton Berle was notorious for joke-stealing, and more-or-less admitted it. In one comedy routine, as I recall, Henny Youngman told a joke, and Berle replied, “I wish I’d said that!” Youngman’s response: “Don’t worry, you will!”
On an old “What’s My Line,” Red Skelton was the Mystery Guest, and Fred Allen was on the panel. Fred said, “I feel like I should know you are. Do you do your own writing?” Red said, “Yes. Actually I’ve stolen a good deal of your material.” Fred said, “Is your first name a color, by any chance?”
There use to be a guy in Chicago who tracked jokes going back to the earliest vaudeville acts. People could contact him with a joke and he could tell them who used it first.
Mr. Pastis is enacting an homage [stealing] from THE MARVELOUS MRS. MAISEL, which begins with her discovering that her husband is stealing, badly, from Bob Newhart—an unbelievable situation, considering that Newhart’s album was extremely popular, and someone in the audience would’ve shouted the husband down within seconds.
Jokes are meant to be shared. Every joke I know has been passed around and around and around. If I hear a joke and decide I want to use it for myself I will make a few alterations so it fits my style better. But I neither claim to have invented the joke myself, nor feel any obligation to credit whoever told it to me. Not least of all because I’m quite certain that whoever told it to me did not invent it from whole cloth either.
BasilBruce 3 months ago
You can’t make an homage without breaking some eggs.
Bilan 3 months ago
It’s a good thing we don’t need to cite every comic that originally told the joke.
Johnny Q Premium Member 3 months ago
“Good writers borrow. Great writers steal”—Mark Twain
syzygy47 3 months ago
When i use the ideas of others, whenever possible I include attribution. It’s just as important to acknowledge you were paying attention
blunebottle 3 months ago
He learned from the current Pres & VP.
iggyman 3 months ago
I believe it’s called plagiarism in writing, but in jokes as well?
iggyman 3 months ago
You might be learning the wrong things, Pig!
Zykoic 3 months ago
So those book excerpts and familiar speeches I hear are homages?
minty_Joe 3 months ago
Okay, Rat. Let’s not turn this into another Carlos Mencia (aka Ned Holness) situation. We all know what happened there.
Sephten 3 months ago
Steal from one, it’s plagiarism; steal from many, it’s research.
Steve_The_Beard 3 months ago
From the great Tom Lehrer… I am never forget the day I first meet the great Lobachevsky In one word he told me secret of success in mathematics Plagiarize Plagiarize Let no one else’s work evade your eyes Remember why the good Lord made your eyes So don’t shade your eyes But plagiarize, plagiarize, plagiarize Only be sure always to call it please “Research”
win.45mag 3 months ago
And yet, all I hear is crickets. Not a very good stand up guy. They didn’t even smile.
steveh64 3 months ago
Milton Berle was notorious for joke-stealing, and more-or-less admitted it. In one comedy routine, as I recall, Henny Youngman told a joke, and Berle replied, “I wish I’d said that!” Youngman’s response: “Don’t worry, you will!”
Gent 3 months ago
Me always pay homage to great Yogi.
Huckleberry Hiroshima 3 months ago
Good old homage plagarizing. I wonder how you spell plagarizing. No coffee yet so not looking it up. lol, etc…….
Croc Holliday 3 months ago
Foxtrot did a nice riff on this when they borrowed from C&H’s snowmen.
Count Olaf Premium Member 3 months ago
Rat is a Tribute Comic doing covers. “A piece of string walks into a bar…”
Goat from PBS 3 months ago
Makes me wonder how many “homages” Stephan has put in his strip.
Ignatz Premium Member 3 months ago
On an old “What’s My Line,” Red Skelton was the Mystery Guest, and Fred Allen was on the panel. Fred said, “I feel like I should know you are. Do you do your own writing?” Red said, “Yes. Actually I’ve stolen a good deal of your material.” Fred said, “Is your first name a color, by any chance?”
david_42 3 months ago
There use to be a guy in Chicago who tracked jokes going back to the earliest vaudeville acts. People could contact him with a joke and he could tell them who used it first.
mindjob 3 months ago
Now he’s going to put them in a book and say he wrote them himself
Ellis97 3 months ago
I wonder what stand up comedian they are honoring.
ladykat 3 months ago
Plagiarism.
Snoopy Copter 3 months ago
Is it pronounced O-mage or HO-mage?
MatthewJB 3 months ago
Mr. Pastis is enacting an homage [stealing] from THE MARVELOUS MRS. MAISEL, which begins with her discovering that her husband is stealing, badly, from Bob Newhart—an unbelievable situation, considering that Newhart’s album was extremely popular, and someone in the audience would’ve shouted the husband down within seconds.
ChessPirate 3 months ago
Rat is “The Thief of Bad Gags”… (a nickname originally aimed at Milton Berle)
I have noticed a good many of The Three Stooges routine plots were done earlier by Laurel and Hardy, reworked to play to the Stooges’ type of comedy…
krisjackson01 3 months ago
“I only steal from the best.” —Pablo Picasso
tuliplover 3 months ago
In music, it’s called “Sampling”. In my world, it’s called “Stealing”.
DaBump Premium Member 3 months ago
Hey, some of the favorite jokes of some of the greatest comedians were about how much of their material was stolen!
zeexenon 3 months ago
Soon, all Americans must realize our long slow but sure trend and give formal acknowledgment by a vassal of allegiance to his lord under feudal law.
[Unnamed Reader - 14b4ce] 3 months ago
Milton Berle still has disciples
smartty cat 3 months ago
Rat-fink that he is.
John Jorgensen 3 months ago
Jokes are meant to be shared. Every joke I know has been passed around and around and around. If I hear a joke and decide I want to use it for myself I will make a few alterations so it fits my style better. But I neither claim to have invented the joke myself, nor feel any obligation to credit whoever told it to me. Not least of all because I’m quite certain that whoever told it to me did not invent it from whole cloth either.
Bilan 3 months ago
And in science, it’s called standing on the shoulder of giants.
christelisbetty 3 months ago
Who wrote the first “knock knock joke” ?
Cerabooge 3 months ago
Who’d you steal this idea from?
krisjackson01 3 months ago
And then there’s allusion. I titled a chapter “On the Beach” as an allusion to Nevil Shute’s great novel, its title itself an allusion to TS Elliot.
wildlandwaters 3 months ago
Rat’s a stable genius!
eddi-TBH 3 months ago
Comics swap jokes like trading cards. But the original writers in the back room rarely get credit.
WF11 2 months ago
Copy from one source, it’s plagiarism. Copy from many, it’s research.